There is something wonderfully appropriate about an album called An When being made by a group called Tonstartssbandht. Both phrases appear to have arrived from a neighboring language that does not quite exist, assembled from recognizable pieces but refusing to settle into ordinary meaning. The record begins with a track called “Tonstartssbandht?” as though even its creators are looking at the word with uncertainty. Is that the band’s name, the genre, a question, an invocation, or the noise made by a machine attempting to identify two brothers through a damaged database? In barely more than a minute, the album establishes a world where names remain provisional and songs can change identity while they are being played. This is pop music made by people who clearly love pop music, but who do not believe a song must remain inside its original container once they have opened it.
Andy and Edwin White grew up in Orlando, Florida, but by the time of these recordings they were living between Montreal and New York, developing the band through periods of separation, shared visits and exchanged files. That distance matters. An When does not feel like two musicians standing in one room and documenting a stable repertoire. It feels like correspondence. One brother sends a rhythm, voice or guitar fragment into the air; the other answers from another city, and the reply alters the meaning of the original message. The record was created during the moment when online file exchange was quietly changing what a band could be. A group no longer needed a permanent rehearsal space, a local scene or even simultaneous physical presence. Songs could travel through email, Megaupload and MediaFire, gathering layers as they crossed borders. The method becomes audible in the album’s restless architecture. Ideas arrive, mutate, vanish and occasionally return wearing somebody else’s coat.
“Black Country” is the first fully formed pop song, although “fully formed” is a dangerous phrase to use around Tonstartssbandht. Beneath the damaged surfaces is a genuine melodic instinct, the kind that makes an eccentric recording memorable rather than merely unusual. Its title and central guitar shape appear to playfully glance toward Big Country, but the song quickly disappears into the Whites’ private vocabulary of city life, reverb, interrupted thoughts, repeated syllables and affectionate nonsense. The lyrics move between dealers, trains, Montreal’s Lachine district, sleeplessness and the Doobie Brothers, creating a personal geography assembled from overheard speech and mental debris. The production does not polish those fragments into clarity. It allows them to remain crowded together, much as memories of a city become inseparable from songs heard there, apartments occupied there and people loved there.
Then comes “Little April Showers,” a version of the song from Disney’s Bambi. Its placement is perfect because it destroys any theory the listener may have developed during “Black Country.” Rather than treating the song as an ironic novelty, the brothers recognize the strangeness already inside it. The original composition translates falling rain into overlapping voices, rhythmic syllables and miniature orchestral weather. Tonstartssbandht bring those elements into their own homemade vocal laboratory, where sweetness and distortion are not opposites. The result connects childhood memory with experimental recording practice. A song encountered through animation becomes raw material decades later, its innocence preserved but refracted through worn equipment, layered voices and adult awareness. It is nostalgic without becoming obedient to nostalgia.
“5FT7” may be the album’s most open-hearted piece. Its repeating declaration, “I’m five foot seven, you know I’m a little buttercup,” is funny, vulnerable and strangely triumphant. The surrounding lyrics imagine travel, Los Angeles, Orlando, Washington, swimming pools, jobs, movies and a possible shared life inside a bungalow. Instead of separating sincerity from absurdity, the song lets them strengthen each other. Affection frequently enters real conversation through jokes, nicknames and deliberately foolish statements because direct emotional language can feel too exposed. “5FT7” understands that a ridiculous refrain can carry a serious longing. The track’s later life, including a video assembled from period performance footage and its return through subsequent vinyl editions, makes sense. It contains an early blueprint for Tonstartssbandht’s enduring appeal: enormous feeling delivered through a form loose enough to breathe.
The minute-long “Welsh Souper” reduces language to a handful of sounds, including a borrowed Hindi phrase and the emphatic announcement of its title. It behaves like a scrap left on the studio floor that somehow became indispensable. Many bands would either discard such a piece or inflate it into a respectable song. Tonstartssbandht understand that an idea may already be complete after sixty seconds. “Midnite Cobras,” by contrast, pushes outward, piling voices, noise and recurring phrases into one of the record’s most overloaded moments. Melody survives inside the static rather than standing safely above it. The song repeatedly seems ready to collapse, but each breakdown reveals another hook or rhythmic possibility. This tension between destruction and catchiness is central to An When. Noise is not applied after composition as a fashionable coating. It participates in composition, obscuring one path while opening several others.
“Andy Summers” continues the album’s collision of private references and public culture. The Police guitarist becomes a character, a launch mechanism and a phrase whose repetition gradually severs it from its original owner. Books, bicycles, Florida, weather, summer jams and invented spiritual classifications tumble through the track. Meaning accumulates through proximity rather than narrative logic. This is one of the record’s most blog-era qualities. During the late 2000s, online music discovery often resembled wandering through an overgrown personal archive. A song might sit beside an animated GIF, an old photograph, a broken download, an unexplained joke and several references understood only by the uploader’s friends. An When possesses that same collage intelligence. It does not stop to label every object because mystery is part of the hospitality.
By “M’old Jæp,” the human voice has almost replaced the conventional band. The song circles around a Jeep Grand Cherokee, stretching a mundane consumer object into a companion, mantra and vehicle through eternity. Repetition makes the words less intelligible but more emotionally charged. The effect suggests that language has a hidden stage beyond communication, where a phrase repeated enough times becomes texture, rhythm and environment. Edwin would explore related possibilities through his Eola recordings, but An When shows this vocal imagination already functioning inside the brothers’ shared project. Voices do not merely sing melodies. They imitate instruments, create percussion, smudge the border between speech and sound and populate the record with several exaggerated versions of the same two people.
“Walken With Jesus” transforms Spacemen 3’s “Walkin’ with Jesus,” changing one letter and potentially inviting Christopher Walken into the title’s spiritual drama. The joke does not erase the devotion and conflict inside the song. Its narrator has encountered heaven on Earth but expects punishment for choosing earthly pleasure, friendship, confusion and love. Tonstartssbandht accelerate and rearrange the material, emphasizing voices and keyboards rather than simply reproducing the original’s narcotic guitar atmosphere. It becomes less a cover than a transmission received by unfamiliar equipment. This is how influence operates throughout the album. Disney, psychedelic rock, radio pop, devotional music, noise and family humor are not displayed as separate record-store sections. They enter the same bloodstream and emerge as something recognizably related to all of them but owned by none.
The closing sequence, “ORO,” “Imenope” and “Softly Kidding,” moves farther from ordinary song construction. Samples and vocal loops become increasingly self-sufficient, as though the album is dismantling the machinery it used to create its earlier pop songs. “Imenope” is especially suggestive. Its title resembles a compressed recitation of alphabet letters, a child’s learned sequence folding into a single invented word. Repeated voices make that word appear to change without necessarily changing at all. The listener begins hearing subdivisions, phantom syllables and possible meanings generated by expectation. By “Softly Kidding,” the album has reached a place where title, voice, gesture and atmosphere can barely be separated. It does not end with a grand statement. It simply slips beyond the point where the original question can be answered.
The physical history of An When reinforces its character. It began as a self-released CDr, then migrated through tiny cassette editions, digital files and several vinyl incarnations before receiving a wider Fire Talk reissue in 2022. Each version freezes a different stage in the transformation of something that initially belonged to a small, fast-moving network of blogs, basement shows and direct exchanges. The CDr remains especially appropriate. A recordable disc suggests immediacy rather than permanence: make the object, draw or print something for it, send it outward and continue working. Yet these supposedly temporary formats often become the most accurate documents of a musical life because they preserve decisions before history has organized them into a clean career narrative.
Listening now, An When does not merely sound like an early version of the band Tonstartssbandht would become. It contains possibilities they could have pursued forever: psychedelic pop group, vocal ensemble, noise project, electronic duo, classic-rock mutation, devotional prank, archive of brotherly communication. The record’s achievement is that it refuses to choose among them. Its inconsistencies are not problems awaiting correction. They are evidence of two young musicians discovering that identity can remain plural without becoming empty. Later recordings would give their guitar-and-drums performances greater duration, physical power and improvisational space, but this compact album captures the laboratory before any single creature escaped and became dominant.
An When also preserves a specific faith in recording. It believes that an inexpensive or imperfect sound can contain a complete world; that a joke may become sacred through repetition; that a Disney song can coexist with blown-out noise; that brothers living in different cities can build a room together inside exchanged files. The album does not ask whether these combinations are tasteful, marketable or stylistically coherent. It asks whether they produce life. Again and again, the answer is yes. Anyone who encountered the original CDr, cassette editions, early downloads or the Montreal shows surrounding this period may remember details that formal discographies cannot hold. Those memories belong beside the music because An When was never only a finished object. It was a message in motion, and somehow it is still arriving.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.