Private Release – none
Track Listing:
-------------
A1 The Tough Shits - Early Grave
A2 DMX - Reading Raibow
A3 Dump - Raspberry Beret
A4 Ben & Bruno - 100 Grim Reapers
A5 Finn. - You Will Be Replaced...
A6 Electric President - Hum
A7 Fireflies - Flowers
A8 Sparks - Sherlock Holmes
A9 First Floor Power - God Damn Your Fingers
A10 Catlandgrey - Interlude #1
A11 Teddy And The Frat Girls - Clubnite
A12 Polvo - My Kimono
A13 Embrace - Building
B1 Wolfman Jack - Right Now
B2 The Yolks - Sit in Silence
B3 Dylan Nyoukis - Mohair Pants
B4 Directions In Music - (Untitled)4
B5 Dump - When U Were Mine
B6 Enon - Rubber Car
B7 Fire Engines - Hungry Beat
B8 East River Pipe - What Does TS Eliot Know About You
B9 Ego Summit - Illogical
B10 Sectret Boyfriend - Your Hearts Not In It
B11 Chain Of Strength - True Till Death
Made by my friend (Tony Morabith) & me before his death. RIP
-------------
A1 The Tough Shits - Early Grave
A2 DMX - Reading Raibow
A3 Dump - Raspberry Beret
A4 Ben & Bruno - 100 Grim Reapers
A5 Finn. - You Will Be Replaced...
A6 Electric President - Hum
A7 Fireflies - Flowers
A8 Sparks - Sherlock Holmes
A9 First Floor Power - God Damn Your Fingers
A10 Catlandgrey - Interlude #1
A11 Teddy And The Frat Girls - Clubnite
A12 Polvo - My Kimono
A13 Embrace - Building
B1 Wolfman Jack - Right Now
B2 The Yolks - Sit in Silence
B3 Dylan Nyoukis - Mohair Pants
B4 Directions In Music - (Untitled)4
B5 Dump - When U Were Mine
B6 Enon - Rubber Car
B7 Fire Engines - Hungry Beat
B8 East River Pipe - What Does TS Eliot Know About You
B9 Ego Summit - Illogical
B10 Sectret Boyfriend - Your Hearts Not In It
B11 Chain Of Strength - True Till Death
Made by my friend (Tony Morabith) & me before his death. RIP
Sherlock Holmes did not begin with a funeral bell. It began the way many nights between James Boyd and Tony Morabith began: somebody came over, drinks appeared, records and files started moving, tattoo equipment found its way into the room, and the evening loosened itself from whatever plans either man had carried through the door.
They had done versions of this for years. Sometimes the night extended toward a show, a party or separate dates with their girlfriends before the two friends somehow found each other again. Sometimes the destination was simply the room itself. Music, alcohol, conversation, skin, ink and whatever happened next were enough.
By 2015, Tony may have been visiting Oakland from somewhere else or staying near Mosswood Park with people connected to NOBUNNY and other musicians. The exact address has blurred, but the social geometry remains recognizable. Tony was nearby again. James had a tape deck, a room at the Purple House and a sequence beginning to form.
James chose most of the songs. He tended to hear mixtapes through movement before language. The next track needed to enter at the correct speed, pressure and emotional temperature. Genre could change completely as long as the body of the tape did not stumble. A garage song might lead into damaged pop, bedroom electronics, punk, collage or something barely identifiable because the pulse beneath them felt related.
Tony, already drinking, would occasionally take control and throw in something James would never have selected at that exact moment. Every few songs, the tape changed drivers.
That is the collaboration inside Sherlock Holmes. James maintains the road. Tony occasionally grabs the steering wheel and points toward a billboard nobody else noticed.
The Tough Shits’ “Early Grave” starts Side A with a compact, forward-moving piece of garage punk. James selected it partly because he wanted Tony to hear the title, but the night did not immediately become a dramatic intervention. The song entered the same atmosphere as the drinks, tattoo plans and ordinary pleasure of being together. Its warning sat inside the room without yet stopping the party.
Tony answered by placing DMX over the Reading Rainbow theme.
The transition is hilarious. It also establishes the rules of the tape. No feeling will be allowed to remain pure for long. Threat becomes children’s television. Seriousness is struck from the side by absurdity. Whatever emotional meaning James places on the table, Tony is likely to set something strange beside it and watch the two objects argue.
This was not avoidance so much as Tony’s method of participation. Humor could keep an evening open after a difficult subject entered it. A heavy statement did not have to be denied, but it might need its knees kicked out before everyone became trapped beneath it.
Dump’s “Raspberry Beret” follows with a homemade tenderness that seems to reduce Prince’s bright pop architecture to a smaller room. The famous melody remains recognizable, but its scale has changed. It sounds less like an event designed for mass recognition and more like someone remembering a song while leaning against bedroom furniture.
Then Ben & Bruno arrive with “100 Grim Reapers.”
The first four tracks already contain a miniature version of the entire tape: an early grave, a children’s show, romantic clothing and a crowd of death figures. Yet the sequence does not feel like a thesis. The tempos fit. The tonal pressure remains steady. Meaning grows afterward, in the spaces between songs, the way weeds appear between pavement slabs without asking whether anybody intended a garden.
Finn.’s “You Will Be Replaced…” is brief and uneasy. It enters almost like a typed notice slipped beneath the door. At the time, it could remain a good title attached to a song that belonged in the sequence. Years later, it develops another argument.
People can be replaced by function. A new neighbor can live down the street. Another musician can play bass. Someone else can occupy the empty place at a party or answer a phone at two in the morning.
A person’s particular way of loving cannot be replaced.
Tony had already demonstrated this years before Sherlock Holmes existed. James met him during a period when North Oakland became an accidental survival structure assembled from punk houses, musicians, disabled passengers, converted buses, free food, pirate radio and people who did not require a clean biography before letting someone sit down.
James had arrived in California in 2007 after leaving Chicago in a suicidal crisis. Aquarius Records became the location where his intended ending changed direction. Andee Connors saw him collapse, called John Benson and placed one life into the hands of another person who knew how to make room.
John had played bass in A Minor Forest, a band James had toured with several times between 1995 and its final tour in 1998. James had left that last tour halfway through, shortly before the group broke up. The band jokingly blamed him, but the joke touched something real. James had often felt like the younger person inside that traveling family, trying to hold together relationships whose fractures he could feel but could not repair.
When John came to get him in 2007, the reunion did not resemble a band story. John simply included James in daily life. For several weeks, before James found work, they spent nearly every day together. James talked through the collapse he had carried across the country. John drove paratransit for Easy Does It, transporting people with disabilities around the Bay Area, and James entered a world built from practical kindness rather than grand declarations.
John knew people everywhere. Musicians, paraplegic passengers, squatters, artists, neighborhood figures and people who had assembled entire lives outside normal institutions passed through his days. He also had an old AC Transit bus converted into a mobile music venue. Bands played inside it constantly. The city briefly seemed capable of producing a show anywhere a vehicle could stop.
The Purple House at 5716 Genoa Street belonged to this ecosystem. It had carried punk history through different generations, partly through people scattered from Barrington Hall after its closure. Free Radio Berkeley had once operated from a downstairs room. Food Not Bombs used the house as a Sunday cooking space for years. Vegetables, bread and pizza appeared on the porch. The free box absorbed neighborhood objects and redistributed them according to whoever needed what had been discarded.
Around the corner stood Hellarity at 537 57th Street, a more openly unstable squat with its own legendary history of court battles, changing owners, eviction payments, returns and people occupying the gaps between official versions of reality.
The Purple House and Hellarity were close enough for their backyards to nearly touch. One had become the somewhat older, more continuous sibling of the other. Both gave shelter to people for whom conventional shelter often arrived with too many conditions.
Tony and Alan Dunn drove from Cleveland to Oakland in a van and found Hellarity needing occupants. Tony entered James’s life through that tiny North Oakland radius.
During a cold Christmas season, when most people had left to visit families or partners, James and Tony remained. The Purple House had no central heating system. Blankets, alcohol and human company supplied what warmth existed. James cried about his daughters and the life he had left in Chicago. Tony stayed near him.
This was not dramatic heroism. It was the kind of care that becomes visible only later: remaining in a room, letting somebody repeat the same grief, knowing when to make a joke and when not to leave.
When James’s daughters came to live with him in 2010, Tony was delighted. He loved them, and his understanding of family did not require simple biology or ordinary household boundaries. The friendship extended through parenthood, neighborhood life, music, dating, drinking and all the small occasions that rarely survive into official history.
Electric President’s “Hum” arrives after “You Will Be Replaced…” and feels like the continuation of something beneath speech. A hum can be comfort, machinery, electricity or the involuntary sound made when words have become unnecessary. The tape’s surface becomes less crowded for a moment.
Fireflies’ “Flowers” follows. The song opens into a soft emotional field without abandoning the pace James has been maintaining. Flowers do not yet belong to graves. They can remain gifts, color, attraction, apology or simply the title of a song that sounds correct in this particular position.
Then Tony chooses Sparks’ “Sherlock Holmes.”
The tape receives its name after it has already begun becoming itself.
This matters because Sherlock Holmes was not a concept imposed upon the sequence. It was a discovery made inside the night. Tony’s contribution supplied the title, but the title then seemed to illuminate everything around it.
A detective examines relations. A mark becomes meaningful because it appears beside another mark. A speck of dirt, an odd phrase, a timing discrepancy or a piece of fabric acquires force through placement.
A mixtape works similarly. No song has to surrender its original meaning, but every song changes slightly according to its neighbors.
“Early Grave” beside DMX becomes less solemn and more human.
“Raspberry Beret” beside “100 Grim Reapers” becomes a bright object surrounded by death.
“You Will Be Replaced…” becomes stranger when followed by a hum and flowers.
Sherlock Holmes enters and suddenly the listener starts looking backward for clues.
The danger is that hindsight can invent a mystery where none existed. Tony’s later death does not mean the tape predicted it. The night had not begun as a vigil. Two friends were hanging out, drinking, planning tattoos and making music together because that was something they enjoyed.
The serious conversation came later.
By then, the title track had already entered the cassette. The party had already found its rhythm. The warning at the beginning had been heard, joked around and carried forward.
At some point, James told Tony what had become difficult to keep inside casual conversation. Tony’s drinking was too extreme. This was not their first discussion about detox or rehabilitation. The subject had appeared before because the consequences had already entered their friendship.
James had daughters to raise. By around 2013, he had needed to establish a limit on nights with Tony. There was a point when the drinking became too wild and the visit had to end. Morning required elementary-school routines, breakfast, getting dressed and delivering children into a world that did not care how late the adults had stayed awake.
The boundary was not punishment. It was an acknowledgment that love without limits could become another route toward damage.
On the Sherlock Holmes night, James told Tony that he believed the drinking would eventually kill him. He asked him to enter treatment. They cried.
This conversation did not transform the entire tape into a memorial while it was being made. It became one element inside a larger night. Drinking continued. Songs continued. The friends remained themselves rather than turning instantly into symbols.
That is where the earlier versions of the write-up tilted too far. Death eventually entered the story, but Tony was not death walking around in a musician’s body. He was a friend with jokes, taste, affection, recklessness and the ability to throw DMX onto a mixtape at exactly the moment James had created too much emotional gravity.
First Floor Power’s “God Damn Your Fingers” comes after Sparks and pulls the tape from deduction back toward touch. Fingers operate tattoo machines, turn records, press buttons, hold drinks and point during arguments. They are the instruments through which private intention becomes physical evidence.
Catlandgrey’s interlude offers a brief chamber of altered atmosphere, an excerpt from something called A Bald Cell’s Diary. The title introduces confinement, writing and bodily oddness without requiring the listener to understand the source. It works as a corridor between songs.
Teddy and the Frat Girls’ “Clubnite” kicks the door open with crude social energy. Polvo’s “My Kimono” follows through guitar shapes that seem to turn corners inside themselves. Embrace’s “Building” closes the first side with a slower emotional weight.
“Building” does not need to become an obvious symbol, yet the title inevitably gathers the houses behind the tape.
The Purple House was built in 1908, but the structure James knew was continually rebuilt through use. A room could be a bedroom, rehearsal area, pirate-radio station, temporary refuge or place where two friends made a mixtape while drinking and preparing to tattoo each other.
Hellarity was also a building whose identity came from occupation more than ownership. Legal paperwork declared one version of the property while the people inside produced another.
James’s life had been redirected by buildings that behaved like communities. Aquarius Records had been one. John Benson’s converted bus had been another, a moving room for music. The Purple House gave James time to imagine surviving. Hellarity delivered Tony into the neighborhood.
Side A ends without resolving any of this. The tape flips.
Depending upon the version, the sequence around the side break can vary slightly, another reminder that this object had more than one physical life. One handwritten list includes Jacuzzi Boys before Wolfman Jack’s “Right Now,” while another later transfer begins the reverse directly with Wolfman Jack. The mixtape was not guarded like scripture. Copies could mutate.
“Right Now” turns radio language into command. The phrase could advertise a product, introduce a record or insist upon an action that cannot be delayed. Inside the later history of the tape, it carries the urgency of treatment, but in the original room it also functions as propulsion. Side B is here. Start again.
The Yolks’ “Sit in Silence” immediately complicates that urgency. Right now, sit in silence.
This is one of the tape’s best transitions because the titles oppose each other while the music preserves continuity. Urgency meets stillness without the sequence feeling broken.
Dylan Nyoukis’ “Mohair Pants” follows with a title too tactile and absurd to support any heavy interpretation for long. It reminds the listener that James and Tony were not producing an art-therapy assignment. Their taste allowed serious beauty, punk comedy, avant-garde sound and pure nonsense to share the same cassette.
Directions in Music supplies an untitled piece, opening another wordless passage before Dump returns with “When U Were Mine.”
The earlier Dump track had transformed “Raspberry Beret,” a song built around a remembered encounter and a vivid article of clothing. The second Prince cover enters through loss. The grammatical tense looks backward.
At the time, this was still a song chosen for its mood, familiarity and place in the sequence. After Tony died, the title acquired a different room. This is not prophecy. It is one of the ways music continues changing after everyone involved has stopped touching it.
A record does not know which future memory will eventually claim it.
Enon’s “Rubber Car” pulls the tape out of reflection through unstable motion. Fire Engines’ “Hungry Beat” gives rhythm appetite. The sequence starts moving outward again.
East River Pipe asks, “What Does T.S. Eliot Know About You?”
The title challenges every attempt to turn Tony into a clean literary subject.
What does any writer know about the way he entered a room, the exact tone of a joke, the timing of his DMX choice or the way he cared for James during that first cold Christmas? What can an obituary explain about years of friendship compressed into ordinary visits?
Public history prefers stable nouns: musician, alcoholic, friend, neighbor.
Private memory is made from verbs: stayed, listened, drank, interrupted, laughed, loved, left, returned.
Ego Summit’s “Illogical” follows and quietly defeats the detective. Sherlock Holmes can examine evidence, but logic cannot always explain the human need beneath self-destructive behavior. Addiction may appear irrational while still performing a function inside the person. It can soften panic, mute memory, supply social ease or create a temporary feeling of control.
Recognizing the function does not remove the danger. It explains why information alone may fail.
James and Tony knew the facts. The conversation was not the first time the consequences had been named. Knowledge existed in the room alongside the drinks.
Secret Boyfriend’s “Your Heart’s Not in It” arrives near the end. The title can suggest romantic withdrawal, emotional exhaustion or a person continuing an action after the internal reason has disappeared. The song does not have to testify about Tony. It belongs in the sequence first as sound. Yet the words continue generating relations around it.
Chain of Strength closes with “True Till Death.”
The phrase lands with hardcore certainty. Loyalty remains pure until the body stops. The cassette now appears to have constructed a bridge from “Early Grave” to “True Till Death,” but the bridge formed through feeling, pacing and shared choice rather than a planned argument.
This is where the tape becomes more interesting than a consciously written concept album. The unconscious relationships are not hidden messages from another world. They are evidence that emotional knowledge can influence selection before the conscious mind has translated it into language.
James knew Tony’s drinking frightened him.
James also wanted to hang out, make a tape, do tattoos and enjoy his friend.
Both realities entered the sequence.
The original cassette carries that night more intimately than the later editions. It is a Fuji ZII 60, a high-position tape with a black shell and pale hubs. The factory language, “Master quality high position tape,” remains visible beneath large white painted characters.
One side says SHERLOCK.
The other says HOLMES.
The title is physically incomplete until the cassette is turned over.
The lettering resembles a private script rather than an ordinary label. The forms bend and flare, as though the alphabet has been forced through a personal filter. They sit across the existing Fuji design instead of replacing it.
The original cover is a field of hundreds of tiny white shapes scattered across black. They resemble broken letters, short paths, electrical fragments or the tracks of microscopic creatures. The eye searches for a repeated system but cannot settle upon one.
The track list is handwritten on the reverse, surrounded by another dense field of marks. Oakland Mixtape Club appears at the bottom. This was before James fully understood Private Release as the name for the wider artistic practice these objects were becoming.
The original is unmistakably handmade. Its strength comes partly from that immediacy. It belongs to one night, one room and the hands that produced it.
Later copies changed the problem.
James wanted to give the mixtape to other people, including Pookie from Pookie and the Poodles, a friendship that had come through Tony. Recreating the entire handwritten cover each time would have turned circulation into endless repetition of labor. A reproducible J-card allowed the object to travel without becoming anonymous.
One later edition uses a black-and-white image of a silent-era woman holding a dark cat. SHERLOCK is painted beneath her. The reverse carries the handwritten track list and the line:
Tony’s last mixtape to me...
That sentence belongs to a later time. It could not have appeared on the original tape because Tony was still alive when the first object was made.
The cassette inside is a transparent Memorex 120 with bright yellow hubs and colored geometric shapes. Red painted lettering divides SHERLOCK and HOLMES between the sides. The visual language is more controlled and reproducible, yet still visibly handled.
Another J-card uses a collage of Taylor Swift, a woolly mammoth, movie-guide text, plaid fabric and commercial catalog material. That version belongs more clearly to the developing Private Release method: found print reorganized until ordinary images enter a new private system.
The difference between the original and the later copies is not a hierarchy where one is authentic and the rest are inferior. They represent two stages of understanding.
The first object records an event.
The later objects allow the event to circulate.
James began realizing that “homemade” did not have to mean visually apologetic or accidental. Reproduction could become part of the artwork. A cover could be made once, copied and distributed without pretending to be a factory release. The personal method could remain visible even when several objects shared the same design.
That shift helped Private Release become itself.
The photograph of Tony at Divine’s grave belongs beside these objects because it captures his particular collision of irreverence and affection. Divine, central to John Waters’s films, had already transformed insult, excess and rejection into an underground form of power. Tony crouches barefoot beside the grave marker and touches it with his tongue.
After Tony’s death, the image inevitably attracts foreshadowing. A living person is physically joking with a monument to someone dead. But the photograph should be allowed to remain funny before it becomes tragic.
Tony is not studying his future.
He is clowning around at Divine’s grave.
His bare foot is in the grass. His tongue touches stone. Somebody with him recognizes the gesture as worth photographing.
The same protection belongs to Sherlock Holmes. Hindsight cannot be permitted to turn every title into an obituary. Tony was alive while making it. He was selecting music, drinking, hanging out and interrupting James’s smoother emotional movement with choices that kept the tape unpredictable.
The later conversation about treatment became part of the night, but it was not the whole night.
James and Tony had a long-established ritual of meeting, splitting apart into other social lives and finding each other again. They might attend shows, parties or dates separately, then regroup. Friendship became a recurring point of return.
Sherlock Holmes is one return preserved on tape.
The sequence moves according to James’s sense of tempo and mood, but Tony’s periodic selections puncture the continuity. DMX is the clearest interruption. Sparks is the most consequential because it names the object.
This uneven structure feels more truthful than a perfectly shared alternating playlist. Collaboration does not require equal arithmetic. One person may provide most of the road while another changes the meaning of the journey through several well-placed turns.
The tape’s later grief comes from the fact that those turns can no longer be added.
Tony’s selections stop at twenty-five tracks.
The blank future remains outside the cassette.
Yet the object does not preserve only loss. It preserves the pattern by which two friends occupied a room together. James chooses through feeling. Tony occasionally inserts a crooked answer. The songs continue.
“Early Grave” is serious, but DMX follows.
“100 Grim Reapers” appears, but so do a raspberry beret and flowers.
“You Will Be Replaced…” is answered by a friendship that proves the title wrong.
“Building” closes one side inside a history of houses that caught people falling from ordinary life.
“Right Now” meets “Sit in Silence.”
Sherlock Holmes meets “Illogical.”
The tape ends “True Till Death,” but the living night does not behave like a slogan.
James and Tony drink, plan tattoos, argue, laugh and eventually cry. The emotional register changes several times because actual friendship cannot remain inside one genre.
That is the write-up the cassette needs. Not a biography stapled to a track list and not a detective story in which every song predicts the ending. Sherlock Holmes is a night whose later history keeps shining backward through it, altering details without erasing their first meanings.
The first tape belongs to Tony and James in the room.
The later copies belong to everyone the friendship reached.
Side A says SHERLOCK.
Side B says HOLMES.
The answer is not hidden in the lyrics.
It is in the way one song hands the night to another.









