DISC 1 - Miles Davis Quintet, 1960
Track 1-4: Unknown venue, probably West Germany
between March 21 and April 10, 1960
Track 5-7: Kongresshalle, Frankfurt am Main, West Germany
March 30, 1960
DISC 2: John Coltrane Quintet
Olympia Theatre, Paris, Nov. 18, 1961
DISC 3
Track 1-3: Olympia Theatre Paris Nov. 18, 1961, Second concert (11:30 pm)
Track 4: Konserthuset Stockholm Nov. 23, 1961, second set
Track 5: Auditorium Maximum Freie University Berlin, West Germany Dec. 2, 1961
DISC 4:
Falkonercentret Copenhagen, Denmark Nov. 20, 1961
Disc 5
Track 1-4: Kulttuuritalo Helsinki, Finland Nov. 22, 1961, Second concert (9:15 pm)
Track 5-11: Südwestfunk TV Studio Baden-Baden, West Germany Dec. 4th 1961 (incorrectly attributed to Nov. 24 1961)
Disc 6
Track 1-3: Kongresshalle Frankfurt am Main, West Germany Nov. 27, 1961
Track4-6: Liederhalle Stuttgart Nov. 29, 1961
DISC 7: John Coltrane Quartet, 1962:
Falkonercentret, Copenhagen, Denmark, Nov. 22, 1962
DISC 8: John Coltrane Quartet, 1962:
Track 1.4: Falkonercentret, Copenhagen, Denmark, Nov. 22, 1962--continued
Track 5: Stefaniensall, Graz, Nov. 28, 1962
DISC 9:
Track 1-6: Showboat, Philadelphia, June (possibly 10, 17, or 24) 1963
Track 7: Tivoli Koncertsal, Copenhagen, Denmark, Oct. 25, 1963
DISC 10:
Track 1-5: Tivoli Koncertsal Copenhagen, Denmark Oct. 25, 1963--continued
Track 6: Date and location uncertain, may be from 1962
DISC 11
Liederhalle, Stuttgart, Nov. 4, 1963
DISC 12
Liederhalle, Stuttgart, Nov. 4, 1963--continued
Live Trane: Underground is not simply an enormous collection of John Coltrane concert recordings. It is a time-lapse photograph of transformation, thirteen hours in which one can hear a musician leaving Miles Davis, forming his own ensemble, absorbing Eric Dolphy, stabilizing the Classic Quartet and arriving at the threshold of the spiritual and musical breakthroughs that would define the remaining years of his life. The same compositions return from city to city, but repetition never means stasis. “My Favorite Things,” “Impressions,” “I Want to Talk About You,” “Naima” and “Mr. P.C.” become measuring instruments placed against a rapidly expanding consciousness. Every performance asks how much further the material can be stretched without losing its identity, and Coltrane repeatedly discovers that identity is not a fixed shape. It is a principle strong enough to survive continuous transformation.
The collection was assembled in 2004 as six paired CD-R volumes, each wrapped in beautifully fabricated artwork modeled after Reid Miles’ classic Blue Note designs. The imaginary imprint is called Wrong Note rather than Blue Note, and the back covers carry the declaration “Never for sale, live for sharing.” The joke is affectionate but also philosophically exact. These recordings exist because listeners, collectors, radio engineers, tape traders and early file-sharing communities refused to allow performances to disappear merely because they did not belong to an official album campaign. Tape generations, rebroadcasts, incomplete sources, uncertain dates, duplicated tracks and abrupt endings remain embedded in the archive. The imperfections are not debris surrounding the music. They reveal the underground system through which the music survived.
The first disc begins before Coltrane has formally become the leader whose name dominates the box. He is still standing beside Miles Davis during the spring 1960 European tour, accompanied by Wynton Kelly, Paul Chambers and Jimmy Cobb. The group had recently participated in Kind of Blue, but these concerts already show how sharply Miles and Coltrane were diverging. Miles reduces. Coltrane multiplies. Miles’ trumpet phrases enter the music with the clarity of carefully chosen objects placed inside open space. Coltrane’s tenor seems determined to examine every molecular possibility within that same space, filling the modal structures with accelerating runs, repeated fragments, harmonic substitutions and cries that occasionally sound as though the horn is attempting to exceed the lungs and hands operating it.
That contrast does not weaken the quintet. It electrifies it. On “So What,” the rhythm section establishes the famous modal platform, but Coltrane treats simplicity not as permission to relax but as an invitation to investigate. The reduced harmonic movement gives him room to test patterns against the entire register of the tenor. His solo is not merely longer or busier than Miles’. It proposes another relationship to time. Miles allows silence to retain authority; Coltrane enters silence as though it contains something concealed that disciplined effort might uncover.
European audiences had welcomed American jazz as an art of freedom, refinement and modernity, but some were unprepared for the intensity Coltrane brought into the familiar Miles Davis repertoire. During the 1960 tour he was asked whether the anger listeners heard in his playing reflected actual anger. His response was revealing: he was attempting many things simultaneously and had not yet sorted all of them out. Live Trane: Underground allows us to hear that sorting process across years. What could sound to an audience like excess or hostility was partly the noise of a musical intelligence refusing to discard possibilities before understanding them.
The opening disc therefore contains a departure before anyone has physically left the band. The tunes remain Miles Davis tunes, the rhythm section continues functioning with disciplined elegance and the concert presentation belongs to the Jazz at the Philharmonic touring system. Yet Coltrane’s solos already seem to come from another ensemble waiting to exist. When he reappears on the second disc in Paris during November 1961, that ensemble has arrived.
The difference is immediate. Eric Dolphy stands beside him on alto saxophone, flute and, elsewhere in the tour, bass clarinet. McCoy Tyner is at the piano, Reggie Workman on bass and Elvin Jones on drums. The music is no longer organized around the contrast between Miles’ restraint and Coltrane’s proliferation. Everyone now participates in expansion. Tyner creates enormous harmonic floors using fourths, suspended chords and repeated rhythmic figures. Workman gives the music a dark, tensile center. Jones does not simply maintain time; he surrounds it with rolling subdivisions, cymbal weather and accents that make every measure appear to contain several simultaneous directions.
Dolphy is not an ornament added to Coltrane’s sound. He is a destabilizing second intelligence. His alto can be dry, acerbic and sharply angular where Coltrane’s tenor is torrential and vocal. His flute introduces a thin, airborne movement above the rhythm section’s weight, while the bass clarinet seems to open a tunnel beneath it. Their interactions do not resemble two soloists politely taking turns. Each changes the scale of the musical environment in which the other must operate.
The 1961 European tour occupies the great central cathedral of this archive. Paris, Copenhagen, Helsinki, Stockholm, Berlin, Baden-Baden, Frankfurt and Stuttgart preserve different portions of a repertoire being repeatedly dismantled and rebuilt. Some listeners may initially see the recurring titles as duplication. Why keep so many versions of “My Favorite Things” or “Impressions”? Because the subject of the collection is not the composition alone. It is the nightly interaction among repertoire, room, audience, energy and discovery.
A studio recording asks the musician to produce a durable statement. A tour asks the musician to live inside that statement until it begins revealing doors that were invisible during its creation. Every night the same tune awakens under different conditions. The hall has another acoustic. The piano responds differently. The bass is easier or harder to hear. Jones strikes one cymbal accent that sends Coltrane toward an unforeseen phrase. Dolphy enters from another angle. A familiar theme becomes a launch site whose terrain has been altered since the previous evening.
“My Favorite Things” is the most obvious example. Coltrane had already transformed the Rodgers and Hammerstein song by moving it to soprano saxophone and allowing its waltz figure to revolve around modal centers. In these concerts it becomes something much larger than an ingenious reinterpretation of a Broadway melody. The theme begins to function as a home frequency. Coltrane can leave it for fifteen, twenty or nearly thirty minutes, entering increasingly remote regions of repetition and harmonic pressure, because the listener continues sensing that small circular melody somewhere beneath the expedition.
The Copenhagen performance lasts nearly twenty-nine minutes and is preceded by two false starts. Those fragments are invaluable. Official albums tend to present mastery after uncertainty has been removed. Here the machine does not initially engage. The musicians begin, stop, adjust and begin again. The false starts make the final performance feel less like spontaneous magic descending perfectly formed than a human structure requiring alignment. Once the quartet and Dolphy enter the complete performance, the previous hesitation becomes fuel. The music does not merely recover; it seems determined to justify its continuation.
Coltrane’s soprano tone during these performances is narrow, penetrating and strangely physical. It can resemble a devotional singer, a reed instrument from an imagined folk tradition, an alarm or a beam of light made audible. He often uses short motifs as rotational devices, repeating them while changing emphasis, articulation or placement against Jones’ rhythm. The effect is not mechanical repetition. It is closer to turning an object beneath a lamp and discovering that every angle reveals another surface.
Jones is essential to this transformation. He hears the waltz not as three equal beats but as a revolving field. Triplets divide into further triplets, cymbal accents move across bar lines and the bass drum supplies sudden gravitational disturbances. Coltrane’s repeated figures and Jones’ rolling pulse lock together without becoming rigid. Each produces more momentum for the other. At peak intensity they no longer sound like soloist and accompanist. They become two forms of weather colliding over Tyner and Workman’s ground.
“Impressions” performs a related experiment through a faster, more linear modal framework. It is frequently treated as a vehicle for Coltrane’s technical velocity, but these performances reveal more than speed. The composition lets the band test how long forward motion can be sustained before it becomes another kind of stillness. Coltrane may play hundreds of notes, yet a repeated pitch or contour can create the sensation of circling one spiritual or emotional center. Velocity becomes concentration.
Dolphy’s presence makes the 1961 versions especially volatile. Where Coltrane builds long cumulative arguments, Dolphy can fracture syntax. His phrases leap registers, stop unexpectedly and introduce intervals that seem to question the surrounding harmony. Critics who described the group as “anti-jazz” heard this refusal to preserve comfortable continuity as destruction. Yet the surviving concerts reveal extraordinary listening. Dolphy’s interruptions do not disregard the ensemble. They expose possibilities inside it that a more obedient response would leave untouched.
The controversy around Coltrane and Dolphy now seems almost impossible to understand because their language has entered the foundation of modern improvisation. Live Trane: Underground restores some of the original danger. The music is not dangerous because it is chaotic. It is dangerous because it demonstrates that a respected form can remain alive only by permitting its own rules to be examined. The group knows ballad harmony, blues language, swing and bebop with immense depth. Their freedom is not ignorance of tradition. It is tradition becoming conscious enough to alter itself.
The archive wisely preserves the ballads beside the long modal expeditions. “I Want to Talk About You,” “Every Time We Say Goodbye” and “Naima” dismantle the crude idea that Coltrane’s progress can be measured only through increased intensity. His ballad playing is another form of investigation. He enters a melody slowly, testing the emotional weight of each interval and discovering how much vulnerability a sustained tone can contain.
“I Want to Talk About You” became one of Coltrane’s great live confessionals. Billy Eckstine’s composition gives him a romantic melody, but his tenor gradually removes the protective conventions surrounding romance. The famous unaccompanied cadenzas can feel like language continuing after ordinary speech has failed. Coltrane circles notes, cries through the upper register, descends into rough lower tones and repeatedly approaches resolution without allowing it to become sentimental closure. Desire remains present precisely because fulfillment is deferred.
“Every Time We Say Goodbye” is even more exposed. Cole Porter’s melody carries separation inside its elegance, and Coltrane refuses to treat that sadness as decorative sophistication. The performances are concise relative to the great modal pieces, but they can feel emotionally larger. Tyner’s chords provide a dignified architecture while Coltrane allows the melody to tremble inside it. The result is not softness offered as relief from experimentation. Tenderness becomes one of the experiment’s most demanding conditions.
“Naima,” written for Coltrane’s first wife, likewise demonstrates how stillness can become intense. The composition’s suspended harmonic movement allows the tenor to float rather than advance through ordinary chord changes. In this archive, even an incomplete Stockholm fragment carries immense weight. Its abrupt disappearance makes the performance resemble memory itself: present long enough to establish emotional reality, then cut off by the limitations of the surviving tape.
The fragmentary sources continually remind us that history is not the past preserved whole. It is what escaped destruction. A beginning may be missing because the broadcaster joined late. A solo disappears when tape ran out. One “Impressions” appears twice from different sources; one “Every Time We Say Goodbye” is duplicated and misassigned; dates remain disputed. These imperfections would be unacceptable in a neatly authored studio album, but here they make the archive honest. We are not receiving omniscient access. We are handling evidence.
The Baden-Baden television studio recordings provide a fascinating contrast to the larger concert halls. The pieces are shorter and more concentrated, shaped by broadcast conditions rather than the open duration available during a full evening performance. “My Favorite Things,” “Every Time We Say Goodbye” and “Impressions” are compressed without becoming miniature imitations of the concert versions. The band demonstrates that its language does not depend entirely upon length. A ten-minute performance can still contain the group’s essential tension between theme, departure and return.
By the end of the 1961 section, Eric Dolphy’s presence has altered how we hear Coltrane even when Dolphy is silent. The quintet taught Coltrane that another horn could challenge the center without destroying it, but the partnership was temporary. Dolphy departed, Reggie Workman was replaced by Jimmy Garrison, and the quartet documented on discs seven and eight achieved a different kind of unity.
The Copenhagen 1962 performances introduce the Classic Quartet in full: Coltrane, Tyner, Garrison and Jones. The sound is less crowded than the quintet, but not smaller. Space previously occupied by Dolphy becomes part of the quartet’s expressive vocabulary. Garrison’s bass is especially important. His tone and repeated figures establish foundations strong enough for the other musicians to travel far from the written material. He does not fence the music in. He gives it somewhere meaningful to return.
“Bye Bye Blackbird” stretches beyond twenty-one minutes, transforming a familiar standard into a prolonged negotiation between memory and reinvention. Coltrane states enough of the melody to establish its social world, then begins opening passages inside it. Tyner’s solo does not merely follow. His blocks of harmony and right-hand lines reorganize the room after the tenor’s departure. Jones keeps the pulse in motion while continually altering its surface, and Garrison holds the song’s identity at a depth where it can be felt even when it is no longer being explicitly played.
“Chasin’ the Trane” reveals the quartet’s connection with the raw trio music Coltrane had explored at the Village Vanguard. Without the cushioning effect of a conventional harmonic progression, the tenor can become rougher and more percussive. Phrases emerge as physical units pushed against bass and drums. The title is almost comic because chasing Coltrane is precisely what the listener, rhythm section and perhaps Coltrane himself are doing. The destination keeps moving.
“The Inchworm” demonstrates his peculiar ability to identify a seemingly innocent popular melody and discover an inexhaustible structure inside it. Frank Loesser’s song carries a childlike counting quality, but Coltrane hears recurrence, proportion and the possibility of circular development. He does not mock the simplicity. He trusts it enough to expose it to tremendous pressure. This is one of his defining gifts: the ability to recognize that spiritual and musical depth may be concealed inside material respectable taste considers too ordinary.
“Traneing In” reaches twenty-three minutes and shows how thoroughly the quartet could inhabit blues-derived material without treating the blues as a historical obligation. Garrison and Jones create a vast rhythmic engine while Coltrane moves through patterns that retain the grain of blues speech even at their most technically complex. His intensity does not abandon African American vernacular expression for abstract theory. It repeatedly returns theory to cry, repetition, breath and bodily insistence.
The 1962 discs feel more internally balanced than the 1961 quintet recordings. That balance should not be mistaken for retreat. Coltrane is no longer required to negotiate a second horn, and the quartet can change density almost telepathically. Tyner knows when to increase harmonic pressure and when to withdraw. Garrison can turn a short bass figure into an axis. Jones can imply several tempos while maintaining one collective movement. Coltrane can begin a phrase before the group knows where it will lead because the ensemble has developed the reflexes necessary to construct the road beneath him.
Discs nine and ten introduce another temporary alteration. At Philadelphia’s Showboat in 1963, Roy Haynes replaces Elvin Jones, and portions of the performance operate as a tenor-bass-drums trio because Tyner is absent from much of the surviving material. Haynes does not attempt to imitate Jones’ rolling polyrhythmic ocean. His drumming is lighter on its feet, sharper in outline and filled with crisp, surprising accents. Coltrane responds immediately.
The difference is revelatory. With Jones, Coltrane can sound as though he is climbing through a thunderstorm. With Haynes, his phrases appear to leap across moving platforms. Haynes leaves quick pockets of air, then strikes them with precise snare and cymbal responses. Garrison becomes even more exposed as the harmonic center, while Coltrane is free to alternate between long lines and compact rhythmic cells. The Showboat recording proves that the quartet’s music was not a formula dependent upon one drummer. Its language could absorb another rhythmic personality and reveal a different Coltrane within it.
The uncertain dates and incomplete performances around this section contribute to its nocturnal quality. We know the music occurred; some of its documentary coordinates remain unstable. The recording itself becomes the primary fact. This is one reason underground archives matter. Institutional history often waits for perfect attribution before granting an object legitimacy. Collector culture understands that imperfect evidence may be all that survives and that preservation must sometimes precede certainty.
By October and November 1963, Elvin Jones has returned and the Classic Quartet is operating at terrifying strength. The Copenhagen and Stuttgart recordings do not sound like tentative steps toward the later Coltrane. They sound like a mature language already beginning to strain against its own achievement. “The Promise,” “Afro Blue,” “Impressions,” “My Favorite Things” and “Mr. P.C.” reveal a group capable of producing enormous intensity without sacrificing internal clarity.
“Afro Blue” is particularly important. Mongo Santamaría’s composition gives the quartet a six-beat Afro-Cuban foundation, but Jones turns the meter into a revolving rhythmic sphere. Tyner’s chords arrive with ceremonial force, and Coltrane’s soprano cuts through the ensemble like a human voice calling across a large gathering. The piece anticipates the devotional intensity that would soon become explicit, yet its power is already present without explanatory language. Rhythm, repetition and collective ascent are enough.
“The Promise” carries a different kind of nobility. Its theme is direct and memorable, but the quartet refuses to let lyricism become static. Coltrane’s improvisation seems to search for the conditions under which a promise can remain alive rather than merely spoken. Each return to the theme feels altered by what has happened since the previous statement. Music becomes an ethical action: commitment demonstrated through continuation.
The Stuttgart “Impressions” lasts nearly twenty-nine minutes and stands among the collection’s central monuments. By this point the composition is no longer merely a modal vehicle. It is a complete ecosystem in which each musician can initiate structural change. Coltrane’s tenor moves from fast linear development into repeated cries and compressed motifs. Tyner creates waves of harmonic mass. Garrison’s bass establishes continuity without limiting direction. Jones transforms time into a living surface that can roll, fracture, double and suddenly clarify.
Long Coltrane performances are sometimes described through the language of endurance, as though the central achievement were simply continuing for an extraordinary duration. That misunderstands what the quartet is doing. Duration is not an athletic statistic. It allows perception to change. During the first minutes, listeners follow theme, soloist and harmonic framework. As the piece continues, those categories become less distinct. Repetition magnifies tiny variations. Rhythm becomes environmental. The listener stops waiting for the composition to arrive somewhere else and begins inhabiting its present state.
The final “Mr. P.C.” lasts almost thirty-six minutes. Written for bassist Paul Chambers, the tune began as a compact minor blues and became one of Coltrane’s most reliable concert closers. In Stuttgart it expands into a complete reckoning with the language the quartet has built. The blues form remains the skeleton, but the performance continually grows new bodies around it.
Garrison’s bass carries particular symbolic weight here. The composition honors another bassist, yet Garrison has now become the foundation of Coltrane’s own quartet. He does not erase Chambers’ memory. He activates it within another musical relationship. Jazz tradition works through this kind of living succession. A composition dedicated to one collaborator becomes the field in which another collaborator demonstrates his indispensable identity.
Jones approaches the long performance as though exhaustion were another rhythmic possibility to be transformed rather than feared. His accents continue producing fresh pressure deep into the piece. Tyner’s piano can sound architectural one moment and percussive the next. Coltrane’s tenor repeatedly reaches points that would serve as climaxes in an ordinary performance, then continues beyond them. The effect is not escalation toward one final explosion. It is the discovery that climax can be plural, that intensity can collapse, regenerate and assume another shape.
This extended “Mr. P.C.” is a fitting conclusion because it joins nearly every path explored across the twelve discs. It contains bebop velocity, blues speech, modal repetition, rhythmic abstraction, physical cry and the disciplined endurance of musicians who have developed absolute trust. The Coltrane who played beside Miles in 1960 remains audible inside it, but that earlier language has been metabolized rather than discarded. Growth does not require murdering the past. It requires giving the past more future than it originally seemed to possess.
The collection ends one year before A Love Supreme was recorded, but the spiritual direction associated with that work is already present. Coltrane had spoken in 1961 about becoming freer, beginning without knowing every event that would occur and studying the possibilities of longer constructions. These concerts are the workshop in which that freedom becomes disciplined enough to carry spiritual meaning. The length is not indulgence. It is the time required for searching to become revelation.
It would be a mistake, however, to hear every repeated note as a direct religious symbol or to reduce the musicians to assistants in Coltrane’s private theology. Tyner, Garrison, Workman, Jones, Haynes and Dolphy bring distinct musical histories, personalities and decisions. The transcendent quality arises through collective labor. Coltrane may be the most visible seeker, but he does not build the temple alone.
Live Trane: Underground also demonstrates how misleading the neat chronology of official albums can be. Album histories divide Coltrane into Prestige, Atlantic and Impulse! periods; into hard bop, modal jazz, the Classic Quartet and the avant-garde. Live recordings reveal that these categories overlap. The supposedly earlier language remains active inside later work, while the future appears years before it receives an official title. The road is not a series of locked rooms. It is one structure under continuous renovation.
The fluctuating audio quality strengthens this lesson. Some performances arrive with broadcast clarity; others are veiled by tape hiss, imbalance, compression or generational loss. Coltrane’s horn may suddenly become distant, Jones’ cymbals may dominate, or the bass may seem to transmit through the building’s foundation. These changes remind us that recording is never a neutral window. Every microphone, room, broadcast chain, tape copy and digital transfer interprets the event.
For listeners shaped by noise, drone and experimental music, these imperfections may become another source of fascination. Tape hiss joins cymbal wash. Overload roughens the tenor. A missing frequency creates ghost architecture around the surviving instruments. The performances are not improved by damage, but the damage records their journey. The music has passed through machines and people for decades before reaching this archive.
The “Wrong Note” packaging understands that journey with unusual affection. Each pair of discs receives another saturated color and another Francis Wolff photograph of Coltrane. The typography grants underground recordings the visual dignity of canonical jazz while the parody logo acknowledges their unofficial condition. The artwork does not pretend to be an original Blue Note artifact. It imagines what a parallel record company devoted to circulation rather than ownership might have created.
The statement “Never for sale, live for sharing” turns the set into a small manifesto. The performances were once geographically and temporally exclusive. Only the people in Paris, Copenhagen, Helsinki, Frankfurt, Stuttgart or Philadelphia could hear them. Recording broke that exclusivity, but commercial availability remained inconsistent. Broadcast tapes became bootlegs; bootlegs became collector trees; collector trees entered peer-to-peer networks; peer-to-peer files were reseeded, repackaged, downloaded and eventually preserved again here.
That lineage is not separate from Coltrane’s musical meaning. His work is based upon transmission. A song from a Broadway musical passes into a jazz quartet and becomes a modal ritual. A blues dedicated to Paul Chambers becomes a thirty-six-minute vehicle for Jimmy Garrison and Elvin Jones. A radio signal crosses national borders, is captured on tape and reaches listeners born after every musician onstage has died. Nothing remains unchanged, yet something essential survives every transfer.
Thirteen hours may appear excessive to anyone seeking a concise introduction to John Coltrane. It is excessive, and that excess is the point. A concise anthology tells us what history decided mattered. Live Trane: Underground allows us to hear deciding itself: experiments that recur, versions that fail to reach completion, nights when one tune suddenly opens wider than it did two days earlier, and familiar material becoming unfamiliar through attention.
The reward is not the ability to declare one “My Favorite Things” or “Impressions” definitive. Coltrane’s music resists definitive versions because definitiveness would terminate the search. The archive teaches another kind of listening, one based upon comparison without competition. Paris does not defeat Copenhagen. Stuttgart does not make Helsinki unnecessary. Each performance contains information unavailable to the others because each occurred once, among particular bodies, inside a particular room.
Live Trane: Underground begins with a musician who seems too large for the band he is preparing to leave. It ends with a band becoming large enough to accompany him toward a horizon none of them can yet completely see. Between those points lies one of the most extraordinary periods of development documented in recorded music. Technique becomes language, language becomes environment and environment begins reaching toward prayer.
The final notes of “Mr. P.C.” do not close that process. They leave it vibrating. A Love Supreme, Crescent, Transition, Ascension, Meditations and the final groups remain ahead, but their possibility has already entered the room. Coltrane is still sorting many things at once, only now the sorting itself has become an art of tremendous clarity. The underground tapes preserve not a monument carved after discovery, but the living sound of discovery happening night after night.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.