Shakey Pictures Records – 093624885146 518.39MB FLAC
Carnegie Hall 1970 captures Neil Young alone onstage in New York on December 4, 1970, at a moment when his career was expanding rapidly but his performances could still be almost radically spare. He was 25 years old, had already passed through Buffalo Springfield, released three solo albums, joined Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, and only a few months earlier had issued After the Gold Rush. Instead of presenting that growing stature with a full band, the concert reduces everything to voice, acoustic guitar, piano and occasional harmonica. The result is intimate without feeling small.
The set opens with “Down by the River” and “Cinnamon Girl,” two songs normally associated with the electric force of Crazy Horse. Here they are stripped of distortion and extended guitar interplay, revealing how much melody and melancholy were already built into the writing. “The Loner,” “Southern Man” and later “Cowgirl in the Sand” undergo the same transformation. Nothing feels like an attempt to reproduce the records acoustically. The songs become different objects when all that remains is Young’s voice and the underlying chord structure.
That exposure suits quieter material especially well. “I Am a Child,” “Helpless,” “Tell Me Why,” “Only Love Can Break Your Heart,” “Birds” and “After the Gold Rush” are given enormous amounts of space, with the silence of Carnegie Hall becoming part of the recording. The audience is remarkably attentive, and even pauses for tuning and conversation feel preserved rather than edited away. Young’s voice is fragile, nasal and unmistakable, but in this setting its imperfections become part of the emotional weight rather than something to be disguised.
“Nowadays Clancy Can’t Even Sing” is particularly revealing. The Buffalo Springfield recording had psychedelic arrangement and group texture around it; performed alone at the piano, the song feels much more exposed and troubled. The same is true of “Ohio.” Recorded only months after the Kent State shootings, the solo performance removes the force of the CSNY arrangement but leaves the anger intact. The event it was written about was still recent history when Young stood on the Carnegie Hall stage.
The concert is also valuable because Young was already performing songs that had not yet become familiar parts of his catalog. “Old Man” appears before Harvest existed, while “See the Sky About to Rain” would not receive an official studio release until On the Beach in 1974. “Bad Fog of Loneliness” remained unreleased for many years. Hearing those songs alongside established material makes the concert feel less like a greatest-hits recital than a snapshot of a songwriter moving unusually quickly from one body of work into the next.
“Sugar Mountain” provides some of the set’s personality outside the songs themselves. Young attempts to bring the audience into a singalong, becomes dissatisfied with the result and jokes about it before continuing. Moments like that prevent the recording from becoming overly reverent. Carnegie Hall may be an imposing room, but Young sounds conversational and slightly unpredictable inside it.
The two-disc sequence is generous. Disc One moves from “Down by the River” through “Sugar Mountain,” while Disc Two includes “On the Way Home,” “Old Man,” “After the Gold Rush,” “Cowgirl in the Sand,” “Ohio,” “See the Sky About to Rain” and “Dance Dance Dance.” At roughly ninety-one minutes, the set has enough room to show several sides of Young’s early writing without breaking the concentration of the solo format.
This 2021 release was the first entry in Neil Young’s Official Bootleg Series. The second Carnegie Hall performance from the following night had circulated among collectors for years, but this release presented the previously unavailable first-night multitrack recording. Young himself has described these early archival shows as documents of rapid change in his music, and Carnegie Hall is especially useful in that regard because songs from Buffalo Springfield, Crazy Horse, CSNY and his developing solo catalog all sit together in one performance.
The physical edition keeps the archival presentation deliberately plain. The orange and brown front resembles an old concert document more than a modern live album, with a grainy photograph of Young seated with guitar. The reverse shows Carnegie Hall filled with an audience and prints the recording information in a typewritten style. According to the package, Henry Lewy recorded the concert, with Young and Niko Bolas later producing the release from the original non-Dolby one-inch eight-track tape. The two discs repeat the sparse black-and-white visual language, while this particular set also carries Oakland Public Library labels, barcodes and hub stickers from circulation.
What makes Carnegie Hall 1970 compelling is not rarity alone. It catches familiar songs before familiarity had hardened around them. “Old Man” was still new, “Ohio” was still close to the event that produced it, and several future catalog pieces were still unfinished history. Songs that would eventually become enormous pieces of Neil Young’s public identity are heard here simply as songs being played by one person in a room. Fifty years later, that simplicity is the record’s greatest strength.
—ChatGPT
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.