The Oakland Public Library copy of The Scene of the Crime looks appropriately battered. A white classification sticker sits over the lower-left corner, the disc has been marked through its center, and a large barcode occupies the back above a photograph of a car abandoned at the edge of darkness. The artwork is nearly black, interrupted by harsh white light and the red of Bettye LaVette’s name and track list. There is no glamorous portrait, smiling comeback photograph or tasteful retro decoration. The CD looks like evidence. Something happened here, and the listener has arrived after the damage.
The title refers to Muscle Shoals, Alabama, where LaVette returned in 2007 to make the album, but she was precise about where the real offense occurred. In 1972 she recorded an entire LP at Muscle Shoals Sound for Atlantic Records, backed by musicians who would become part of the region’s legend. The record was mastered, the artwork prepared and a promotional tour booked. Then Atlantic cancelled it without explanation and asked her to return the plane tickets. The tapes sat unheard for decades, supposedly lost, until a French collector located them and released the album in 2000 as Souvenirs. When Terry Gross asked whether going back to Alabama felt like a reunion, LaVette called it something closer to revenge: she had returned with her voice intact, and the industry had failed to kill her. The “crime” was not committed by the musicians in Alabama. It happened in Atlantic’s offices, where a finished career-making record was quietly buried.
By the time The Scene of the Crime appeared in September 2007, LaVette was sixty-one years old and in the strangest phase of a career that had begun forty-five years earlier. Born Betty Jo Haskins in Muskegon, Michigan, and raised in Detroit, she did not grow up singing in church. Her parents’ living room contained a jukebox stocked with blues, country and R&B, while touring gospel performers sometimes passed through the house. At sixteen she recorded “My Man—He’s a Lovin’ Man,” which became an R&B hit and sent her on the road with Ben E. King, Clyde McPhatter and another newcomer, Otis Redding. She expected the next record to carry her into permanent stardom. Instead, promotion failed, contracts dissolved and each opening seemed to close as she reached it.
Her life became a series of near-arrivals. “Let Me Down Easy” gave her another R&B hit in 1965 and placed her on tour with the James Brown Revue. Later sessions produced strong singles, but another planned album disappeared. A 1978 disco record sold well after she had signed away her rights to escape the contract. She spent several years in the touring production of Bubbling Brown Sugar, learning staging from Honi Coles and Cab Calloway. Motown finally released her first proper album in 1982, but a corporate shake-up left it poorly promoted. Through much of the 1990s she worked local Detroit engagements, sometimes playing three shows in one Saturday night. LaVette had never stopped singing. The world had stopped making space for her.
That space began reopening after the lost Muscle Shoals album surfaced in 2000. A live European release followed, then A Woman Like Me won her a comeback award from the Blues Foundation. Her stage show persuaded ANTI- Records to sign her, and I’ve Got My Own Hell to Raise in 2005 brought the broad attention she had been waiting for since adolescence. Producer Joe Henry gave her songs by women including Lucinda Williams, Dolly Parton, Sinéad O’Connor, Fiona Apple and Aimee Mann. LaVette did not treat them as respectful covers. She made each lyric sound extracted from her own history. The Scene of the Crime had to follow that breakthrough without repeating it. The answer was a return to the old wound with a louder band.
ANTI- paired LaVette with the Drive-By Truckers, Southern rock musicians whose relationship to Muscle Shoals was personal as well as musical. Patterson Hood’s father, bassist David Hood, had played on LaVette’s abandoned 1972 album. Spooner Oldham, another musician from those sessions and one of the architects of Southern soul, joined the new record on piano and Wurlitzer. David Hood returned for several tracks, while Patterson Hood, Mike Cooley, Shonna Tucker, Brad Morgan and John Neff formed the rougher central band. The sons and survivors of Muscle Shoals were helping LaVette finish an argument begun before some of them were born.
The collaboration was not peaceful studio tourism. LaVette worked quickly and disliked extended rehearsal. The Truckers preferred to refine arrangements, which she interpreted as a lack of preparation. Patterson Hood later recalled the band pretending to finish for the day, driving around the block and returning after she left so they could rehearse without being scolded. Many vocals were first or early takes. That tension can be heard throughout the album. The musicians leave space while guitars scrape at the edges. LaVette sounds as if patience has expired. She does not float above the band. She confronts it, forcing their Southern rock weight to move at the speed of her phrasing.
“I Still Want to Be Your Baby (Take Me Like I Am)” opens with a low guitar figure, thick bass and Oldham’s electric piano. Written by Eddie Hinton, another gifted Alabama musician damaged by the record business, the song is a plea without submissiveness. LaVette does not ask to be accepted because she promises improvement. She demands recognition in her present condition, scars and all. The guitars churn without becoming a wall, and her voice moves from controlled warning to open insistence. It is the ideal entrance for an artist returning to the place where an earlier version of herself had been rejected.
“Choices,” associated with George Jones, becomes less a country confession than a courtroom statement delivered after the verdict. The lyric considers decisions that cannot be reversed, but LaVette refuses the comfortable wisdom of hindsight. She sounds irritated that wisdom arrived only after the damage. The performance also fits her career with uncomfortable precision. She made choices, but labels, producers and executives made choices about her as well. A song often heard as one man accepting responsibility becomes a more complicated inventory of agency, regret and power.
“Jealousy,” written by Scottish singer Frankie Miller, creeps rather than strikes. Rim shots, Wurlitzer and guitar hover around LaVette while she studies an emotion that poisons both the person feeling it and the person receiving it. Her voice narrows into suspicion, then opens into accusation. She does not begin at maximum intensity. She places pressure on individual words, delays phrases and lets contempt flicker through the spaces. By the time she raises her voice, the song has already been wounded from within.
“You Don’t Know Me at All,” written by Don Henley, John Corey and Stan Lynch, could easily have become polished adult rock. LaVette removes any comfort from it. The title becomes a charge against every lover, executive, critic and audience member who assumed they understood her from a handful of records. The arrangement stays clipped and tense, allowing her to spit the lyric rather than decorate it. Much of The Scene of the Crime works this way: songs written for other people become testimony in a case LaVette has assembled for decades.
Willie Nelson’s “Somebody Pick Up My Pieces” is the album’s exhausted center. LaVette admired Nelson and chose songs according to whether she believed she could inhabit them, not according to genre. The band slows into a bruised country-soul sway while she surveys the aftermath of collapse. She sounds too tired for theater, which makes the song heavier. Pieces remain because the person who broke apart no longer has the strength to gather them. The title could describe her scattered discography: singles across labels, unreleased albums, rights signed away and performances remembered by people who could not buy the records.
“They Call It Love” asks whether the damage people inflict on each other deserves such a generous name. The rhythm has a swampy drag, and Oldham’s keys answer LaVette’s doubts without resolving them. Her skepticism is not cynical distance. She continues wanting love while presenting evidence against it. “The Last Time,” written by John Hiatt, tightens that contradiction into less than three minutes. Pedal steel and guitar frame a promise that one final injury will truly be final, although her delivery suggests she has made the promise before. Her strength is never the absence of weakness. It is her willingness to show weakness without accepting humiliation.
“Talking Old Soldiers” is the album’s most exposed performance. Elton John and Bernie Taupin wrote it as a conversation with an elderly man drinking alone, but LaVette turns the barroom story into a meeting with everyone left behind by time. The arrangement gives her little shelter. She sings about old comrades disappearing until friendship resembles a graveyard, and the cracks in her voice become part of the narrative. At sixty-one, after watching peers become stars, disappear, die or enter history without her, she did not need to imitate the song’s loneliness. The performance is not nostalgia. It is survivor’s fatigue given melody.
Then comes the only song written for the album, “Before the Money Came (The Battle of Bettye LaVette).” Patterson Hood assembled it from stories she told during the sessions. LaVette recounts recording R&B in 1962, knowing David Ruffin before the Temptations, watching friends reach the Grammy stage while she remained in Detroit, and surviving deals that repeatedly collapsed. The band gives the history a hard, almost cheerful bounce, preventing the song from becoming a request for pity. She is not asking the listener to mourn what should have happened. She is establishing seniority and collecting a debt. Forty years of obscurity become credentials rather than shame.
“I Guess We Shouldn’t Talk About That Now” closes the record with unresolved tension. Its title sounds like an attempt to end an argument, but LaVette sings as though silence will only preserve the evidence. Guitars curl around her, and the song refuses the uplift expected from a comeback story. There is no tidy forgiveness, no claim that later recognition repaired earlier neglect. The album ends with the subject still in the room. She does not convert suffering into a reassuring lesson for people who did not suffer it.
In 2007, LaVette was finally experiencing machinery that should have surrounded her decades earlier: a committed label, major press, international touring, serious producers and audiences arriving already aware of her name. The album earned a Grammy nomination, yet success did not turn her into a gracious museum piece. She remained demanding, funny, suspicious and fiercely conscious of lost time. Her performances carried the discipline of someone who had spent years singing for small fees in rooms where nobody cared about her legend because no legend yet existed. She later explained that a singer has to find the place where a song hurts personally. The Scene of the Crime is built from those pressure points.
The library copy makes an accidental extension of the album’s argument. The striped tray, markings, stickers and barcode interrupt the crime-scene imagery, but they also show that the disc continued circulating after the publicity cycle ended. This is not a sealed artifact commemorating a comeback. It is a working copy, borrowed and returned, its surfaces accumulating small injuries while the music remains available. That condition suits Bettye LaVette. Her career was never preserved in perfect packaging. It was scattered, mishandled and repeatedly reassembled.
The Scene of the Crime is often described as a comeback album, but “comeback” suggests that LaVette had gone somewhere. She continued singing while labels stopped listening. The sharper lesson is that recognition and ability do not move together. Talent can exist for decades without the institutions that certify it, and history can mistake poor promotion for artistic failure. In 1972, Bettye LaVette left Muscle Shoals with a finished album and a future that appeared to be opening. In 2007, she returned with the future mostly behind her, a younger rock band waiting for instructions and a voice strong enough to reopen the case. The evidence had not disappeared. It had only been sitting in the dark.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.