The cover contains a horizon but refuses to declare where the horizon is. Loren Connors’s monochrome painting appears to divide into air, water, shore, fog, and dark land, yet each region quietly leaks into the others. A pale band seems to hover above a heavier black field. Tiny marks near the lower edge might be reflected light, distant structures, waves, scratches, or places where the painted surface has remembered the hand that crossed it. The image is called A Coming to Shore No. 21, but it does not show arrival as a clean event. Shore remains something emerging gradually from atmosphere.
Evening air behaves similarly. It cannot be pointed to as an object, yet it changes every visible object. Heat leaves the ground, distances soften, sounds travel differently, and forms that were obvious in afternoon light begin surrendering their borders. Evening is not night, but the certainty of day has already begun withdrawing. Connors and David Grubbs make music inside that transition. Guitar and piano remain recognizable, but neither instrument consistently occupies the expected ground. Notes arrive, fade, reflect, and occasionally become indistinguishable from the space around them.
The label name adds another quiet chamber. Room40 originally points elsewhere, toward codebreaking and hidden transmissions, but here the words become literal again: a room containing forty possible meanings, or the fortieth room reached after all familiar rooms have been exhausted. This music does not feel designed for a large public square. It creates a room whose dimensions are determined by attention. Listen casually and it may seem almost empty. Listen closely and the apparent emptiness develops doors, drafts, distant motion, and the acoustic evidence of things waiting outside sight.
The two musicians first met as a duo more than twenty years earlier in the chapel at Green-Wood Cemetery. That origin remains audible even though Evening Air was recorded in a studio. A chapel teaches sound to behave differently. Silence is no longer the absence between events but part of the architecture holding them apart. A single note can establish height, stone, distance, and the presence of bodies attempting not to disturb one another. Connors and Grubbs do not reproduce church acoustics here. They preserve the courtesy such acoustics demand.
“Evening Air” begins with Grubbs at the piano and Connors on electric guitar. The pairing might suggest a clear division between struck notes and sustained ones, piano providing points while guitar provides atmosphere. The performance immediately complicates that expectation. Grubbs allows chords and isolated tones to hang long enough that the piano begins behaving like weather. Connors’s guitar enters with gestures so thin and carefully placed that they can resemble marks made upon paper rather than amplified strings.
Neither musician appears interested in filling what the other leaves open. This is more unusual than it sounds. Much improvisation is governed by response: one player makes a statement, another replies, and musical intelligence becomes visible through speed of recognition. Connors and Grubbs practice a slower form of recognition. A sound may be answered by allowing it to remain unanswered. Respect becomes audible as restraint.
The title piece does not develop toward conquest. It develops toward acquaintance. Piano and guitar gradually learn the pressure each can exert without forcing the shared air to become private territory. A low piano tone may alter the emotional color of a guitar line without touching it directly. A guitar sound may make the decay of the previous chord suddenly noticeable. The musicians communicate not only through what they play but through what each performance causes us to hear in the other.
“Choir Waits in the Wings” introduces a group of singers who never enter. The title locates them beside the stage, prepared but withheld. Their waiting becomes more powerful than an actual choral entrance because imagination can supply a choir larger than any recording budget. Every sustained guitar tone or gathering piano resonance begins to suggest voices assembling behind a curtain.
A choir traditionally converts separate breathing bodies into collective speech. The individual singer becomes part of a larger mouth. Connors and Grubbs accomplish something almost opposite. Two instrumental voices remain clearly separate while occasionally producing the sensation that a third body has formed between them. The imaginary choir is not added to the music. It appears within the overlap.
The wings are also where performers remain visible to one another while hidden from the audience. They contain preparation, nerves, whispered instructions, props, dust, practical labor, and the ordinary bodies that will soon enter a stage and become symbolic. This album often feels as though it remains in that side space, listening to art before art has completed its public transformation.
The long first side belongs to Grubbs’s piano and Connors’s guitar. The second side changes the furniture. Connors moves to piano for “The Pacific School,” “Enjoyment of Ruins,” and “Child,” while Grubbs takes the electric guitar. The reversal is not presented as a stunt. No announcement tells the listener to admire their versatility. The instruments simply begin revealing different temperaments under different hands.
Connors’s piano playing has a beautiful untrained exactness, not because it lacks knowledge but because it refuses the instrument’s social pressure to demonstrate pianism. The piano carries an enormous historical institution inside it: conservatories, recitals, domestic respectability, composition, virtuosity, and the authority of Western notation. Connors approaches it as a field of available sounds. A key is permitted to be one event rather than evidence of mastery.
“The Pacific School” lasts barely two and a half minutes, yet its title opens toward an ocean and an institution at once. A school can teach doctrine, but it can also be a moving community of fish whose coordination has no visible conductor. Pacific can name an ocean or a condition of peace. The piece hovers among these meanings. Connors’s piano tones appear as dark bodies briefly surfacing while Grubbs’s guitar supplies water, current, or the reflected sky.
The Pacific is too large to be seen as a whole from any shore. It must be understood through local encounters: one wave, harbor, crossing, map, storm, memory, or horizon. The same is true of musical traditions. Nobody hears an entire lineage. A listener receives one record, one performance, one borrowed influence, and gradually imagines the larger sea from those partial contacts.
“Enjoyment of Ruins” is a dangerous title because ruins are beautiful partly through damage someone else may have suffered. A collapsed factory, burned home, deserted institution, or abandoned town can become visual pleasure once the people harmed by its failure have left the frame. Ruin photography often turns consequence into texture.
The piece does not sound triumphant enough to celebrate destruction. Its enjoyment is quieter and more ethically uncertain: the pleasure of hearing forms after their intended function has ended. A broken wall reveals layers hidden during the building’s useful life. A failed machine becomes sculpture. A musical phrase interrupted before resolution exposes the assumptions through which listeners expected it to continue.
Connors and Grubbs do not construct complete melodic buildings and then theatrically destroy them. They begin with fragments already carrying the dignity of remains. The listener is not invited to mourn the missing whole because there may never have been one. Ruin becomes a method of composition in which gaps are original features rather than later damage.
“It’s Snowing Onstage” is the album’s magnificent disturbance. Both musicians take up electric guitars, creating a denser, more confrontational field, and Connors unexpectedly moves to drums. The surprise is not that percussion appears but that it behaves according to no familiar contract. The drums do not stabilize the guitars by supplying a dependable rhythmic floor. They enter like objects dropped into weather.
Snow onstage makes the boundary between representation and environment collapse. Stage snow is artificial weather, flakes manufactured to create an image for an audience. Actual snow would disrupt equipment, alter surfaces, endanger movement, and potentially force the performance to stop. The title leaves us between those conditions. Is the stage convincingly pretending to be outside, or has the outside entered and begun damaging the illusion?
The guitars gather in rougher formations than elsewhere on the record. Their lines push, hover, and occasionally lock together before separating again. Connors’s drumming introduces impacts that seem less interested in measuring time than in proving that time has a body. A drum is struck, air moves, the room answers, and the guitars must continue in a world changed by that impact.
The piece is the longest act of weather on the second side, yet it never becomes a storm in the conventional free-improvisation sense. Its tension comes from unpredictability without aggression. Snow is quiet while transforming every surface it reaches. The track covers the stage this way, changing the visibility and footing of everything already present.
“Child” closes the album in a little over two minutes. Knowing the composition’s history gives the miniature tremendous gravity: a mother’s child killed by the freight trains that once ran through Manhattan’s West Side streets. Yet no voice explains the story here. Connors plays piano while Grubbs’s guitar remains near him, and grief is returned to the condition before narrative organizes it.
A child is a person, a relationship, a future, and a word adults continue using after the person it names has grown or died. To a parent, the child may remain “my child” beyond every alteration of age and even beyond death. Language preserves the relationship while reality removes the body.
The brevity refuses monumental mourning. Public memorials often enlarge grief into architecture because ordinary scale seems incapable of carrying it. “Child” remains small. This makes its absence feel closer. The piece resembles an object kept in a drawer, touched rarely because it contains more feeling than its physical dimensions should permit.
Grubbs does not attempt to replace Suzanne Langille’s absent voice or imitate the emotional information words once carried. His guitar remains a companion to Connors’s piano, perhaps carrying what another person can carry when grief itself cannot be shared equally. One person experiences the central loss; another remains nearby without pretending proximity creates complete understanding.
This has been the ethic of the whole album. Collaboration does not require merging identities. Connors and Grubbs preserve difference so carefully that their moments of convergence become extraordinary. They do not constantly prove that they are listening. They create conditions in which listening can be inferred from the survival of each other’s space.
After two decades, their return is not framed as unfinished business finally completed. Evening Air does not attempt to update Arborvitae, exceed it, or demonstrate everything learned during the interval. Time is allowed to exist between the records without becoming a burden the new music must explain.
This may be why the album feels simultaneously old and newly made. Piano and electric guitar carry no obvious timestamp here. There are no fashionable production gestures announcing 2024. Yet the music could only have been played by these people at this stage of their lives and history together. Timelessness is not the absence of time. It is time felt without being advertised.
Room40 is an ideal home because the label repeatedly treats listening as an active physical and philosophical practice rather than passive receipt. Its releases often enlarge the space between almost nothing and almost too much. Evening Air remains near the first boundary, but close listening reveals that almost nothing may contain an impossible amount.
The cover painting finally stops resembling a landscape and becomes a score. Dark horizontal fields indicate duration. Pale bands indicate air. Tiny marks become notes, boats, distant lamps, or incidents in the painted surface. The coming to shore may be the music approaching audibility, the musicians approaching one another, or the listener gradually recognizing a form that was present before recognition.
Arrival never becomes complete. The shore continues emerging. The choir continues waiting. Snow continues falling upon an indoor stage. The child remains held inside two minutes of sound. Evening enters the room without opening a door.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.