Pain in Progress is where Cold Meat Industry stops looking like three isolated objects and begins behaving like a production system. CMI-01 killed Lille Roger and accidentally created a future. CMI-02 gathered several Swedish projects beneath one shadow and proposed that their different forms of repetition, illness, violence and mechanical pressure might constitute a shared territory. CMI-03 closes the door again, leaving Roger Karmanik alone with forty minutes of tape, but the solitude is no longer the same. He is not simply making another private recording. He is constructing the label’s first full-length interior.
The artist name makes this beginning stranger. Bomb the Daynursery joins two realities that should never occupy the same room. A bomb is designed to transform surroundings through sudden destructive pressure. A day nursery is designed to protect bodies at their most dependent stage, a temporary social world of care, repetition, feeding, sleep and early development. Put the words together and safety becomes a target. Childhood becomes an explosive chamber. Something destructive has been placed among things that have not finished forming.
The name is also an unusually accurate description of this cassette’s historical function. Cold Meat Industry is still in its nursery. Its visual language, distribution network, audience and musical identity remain undeveloped. Pain in Progress introduces the explosive material that will change that young structure from within. The future Brighter Death Now is present, but has not finished acquiring its name. Death industrial is present, but has not yet become a dependable genre category. The bomb has been assembled before anyone knows the size of the building.
Karmanik had used Bomb the Daynursery earlier in the decade, before the sequence of Lille Roger releases that led to Undead. Returning to the older name after formally ending Lille Roger makes Pain in Progress less a straightforward debut than an excavation of a previous self. One identity dies, and rather than moving directly into a new identity, Karmanik retrieves something from before the dead one existed.
This creates a crooked chronology. Artistic development is usually described as forward motion, each project replacing an earlier and less mature form. Karmanik moves backward in order to continue. The old name becomes a passage toward Brighter Death Now. A discarded identity proves more useful than the one that had recently occupied the foreground.
The title captures this unstable transition perfectly. Pain is not complete, interpreted or overcome. It is in progress. The phrase resembles a notice attached to unfinished construction: work in progress, repairs in progress, production in progress. Suffering becomes a process rather than an event. It has stages, materials, repetition and an unknown completion date.
“Progress” normally carries the optimism of improvement. Technology progresses, knowledge progresses, society is expected to progress. Placing pain inside that language reverses the promise. Advancement may increase the capacity to injure, administer, record and reproduce suffering. A system can become more efficient without becoming more humane.
The album itself is also visibly unfinished in the productive sense. Its sounds do not possess the enormous low-frequency architecture, increasingly controlled distortion or polished sepulchral packaging associated with later Cold Meat Industry. The equipment remains close to the surface. Loops, voices, primitive electronics, tape manipulation and repeated impacts do not disappear behind a seamless world. The listener can feel someone constructing the enclosure while already trapped inside it.
This rawness should not be mistaken for an inadequate early attempt at a later style. Pain in Progress does something the mature label could no longer do once its grammar became recognizable. It sounds uncertain about what kind of object it is becoming. Its ugliness has not yet acquired cultural prestige. Its restraint is not automatically understood as death industrial discipline. The cassette must create the conditions through which its own methods can be heard.
The format intensifies that uncertainty. A C40 cassette is not a monumental object. It is light, inexpensive, magnetically vulnerable and small enough to disappear into a drawer. The tape can stretch, hiss, print faint echoes onto itself or be accidentally erased. Cold Meat Industry’s first album-length statement does not arrive carved into durable black vinyl. It arrives upon material that can physically weaken each time it is played.
Cassette listening also imposes two enclosed durations. Side A proceeds until the mechanism stops. The listener turns the object and begins again from the opposite direction. The hand enters the composition at its midpoint. The break is practical rather than symbolic, yet it divides the album’s progression into two physical chambers.
The cover looks like evidence produced by a machine that has damaged its own ability to show clearly. Black space surrounds a pale photographic negative containing two human figures. One appears draped or hooded; the other is nearly consumed by white exposure. Their bodies are visible enough to attract interpretation but not clear enough to yield dependable identities.
A photographic negative ordinarily exists as an intermediate object. It is not the final picture intended for public viewing but the reversed matrix from which that picture can be produced. Light and darkness have exchanged values. What should recede glows, and what should be illuminated becomes black.
Using such an image for Pain in Progress makes the cassette itself resemble an undeveloped state. The full picture has not been printed. The listener receives a negative whose hidden information must be reconstructed mentally. Brighter Death Now will emerge later as one possible print made from this matrix, but the negative contains other possibilities that the later name cannot entirely absorb.
The washed-out figures also appear to be undergoing erasure while the photograph preserves them. Recording behaves similarly. A body may disappear while its voice or action remains available for repetition. The person becomes less present and more reproducible at the same time.
“Shatterer of Earth” begins by giving this fragile cassette an impossibly large scale. The title does not promise damage to a room, body or machine. It names an agency capable of breaking the planet beneath every body and machine. A small domestic playback object contains an event larger than its listener can imagine surviving.
This disproportion is central to underground electronic music. Limited equipment can produce no literal earthquake, but repetition and distortion alter perceived scale. A narrow band of sound, played insistently enough, can suggest pressure with no visible source or boundary. The mind enlarges the event because it cannot locate the mechanism producing it.
The “shatterer” remains unnamed. It could be war, divinity, machinery, geological force, political authority or the sound itself. Karmanik does not need to decide. Naming the action without naming the actor makes destruction feel systemic. The world breaks, but responsibility cannot be located easily enough to confront.
The track also establishes a recurring relationship between immensity and confinement. The title imagines planetary catastrophe while the music remains sealed inside a cassette shell. The Earth is shattered in private, perhaps through headphones or a small bedroom stereo. Apocalyptic scale enters domestic space without attracting public attention.
The title piece follows by making damage temporal. “Shatterer of Earth” implies an overwhelming event; “Pain in Progress” describes what continues after the event cannot remain spectacular. Pain develops, repeats, changes texture and becomes incorporated into daily operation.
The phrase can also identify the artist at work. To construct this music is to organize distress into form. The pain does not disappear through artistic expression. It progresses into another state, becoming tape, rhythm, edition and catalog number. Private pressure acquires a social route.
This transformation creates one of extreme music’s central ambiguities. Giving pain form may provide control, distance and communication. It can also make suffering aesthetically productive, creating a reason to retain or return to it. The artist is no longer merely enduring pain. He is discovering what pain can manufacture.
The composition’s insistence refuses the usual narrative in which difficulty leads toward emotional release. Repetition does not heal the material by carrying it toward a triumphant conclusion. It demonstrates continuation. The piece progresses because time passes, not because the condition improves.
“Certified Dead” introduces administration. Death is no longer simply a physical event. It requires recognition, documentation and authority. Someone must examine the body, determine that life has ended, record a time, sign a form and transform a person into an officially dead person.
Certification is meant to establish certainty. Yet placing it within this album makes certainty feel sinister. The institution does not prevent death or understand the life that preceded it. It confirms that its procedures can continue after the individual no longer can.
The title also describes Karmanik’s succession of project names. Lille Roger had been declared finished through Undead, but the death required another object to certify it. Pain in Progress supplies that certificate while immediately revealing that the person behind the identity remains musically active.
An artistic name can be certified dead while its methods survive inside another name. The certificate verifies a change in public designation, not the disappearance of the underlying obsessions. The dead project leaks into its successor.
The track’s longer duration creates space for this bureaucracy to feel procedural. Death becomes less a dramatic endpoint than a state repeatedly checked and reconfirmed. The system appears unable to trust its own decision, so the certification continues.
On the cassette’s second side, “Dachau - Anthem” presents the most severe ethical problem in the sequence. Dachau is not an invented landscape of torment available for unrestricted metaphor. It is the name of a real place where prisoners were confined, brutalized, exploited and killed. Every artistic use of that name enters a history belonging first to victims and survivors, not to the musician borrowing its force.
The word “anthem” increases the danger. Anthems ordinarily create collective identity. They are sung by people who imagine themselves joined through nation, movement, faith or institution. Attaching that form to a concentration camp can suggest memorial, accusation, grotesque state ceremony or a deliberate refusal to clarify whether the artist is condemning or exploiting the image.
Industrial culture has repeatedly entered this unstable territory. The machinery, uniforms, archives, medical procedures and bureaucratic language of totalitarian violence provide an almost complete visual and sonic vocabulary of dehumanization. Artists may use that vocabulary to expose how modern systems convert people into categories and material. They may also use it because atrocity supplies immediate seriousness to otherwise abstract noise.
The distinction cannot be resolved through intention alone. An artist may believe he is confronting history while listeners receive only an atmosphere of forbidden extremity. A title can encourage research, but it can also reduce the historical site to a portable sign meaning darkness.
Pain in Progress offers little explicit guidance. There is no explanatory essay restoring names, circumstances or individual lives. The cassette’s minimal context leaves the historical weight pressed directly against the music. That absence is uncomfortable, and it should remain uncomfortable.
The correct response is not to sanitize the title or pretend that industrial music never drew energy from atrocity. It is to refuse the transformation of Dachau into fantasy scenery. The track can be heard as an early example of Karmanik’s interest in organized cruelty, but the real history exceeds whatever artistic meaning the composition gives it.
The term “anthem” may also turn against the mechanisms that produced the camp. An anthem reduces complex people into a collective voice. Concentration-camp administration reduced complex people into assigned categories, numbers and laboring bodies. The monumental collective form becomes inseparable from the danger of identity imposed from above.
Yet no formal cleverness makes appropriation innocent. The ethical tension is not a defect that analysis can repair. It is part of the object and part of the history of the genre that formed around objects like it.
“Still Murder” continues this concern through a title with several possible grammars. “Still” can mean murder continues. It can also mean a frozen image, a still photograph preserving one instant from an act whose complete movement has disappeared. It may even function as an instruction: make murder still, hold it in place, prevent it from passing.
All three meanings belong to recorded sound. A violent act can end while its representation continues circulating. A photograph freezes a body within one frame; a sample freezes a voice within repeatable time. Murder becomes historical, but remains active in culture through images, testimony, fiction, news and art.
The title also rejects the comforting belief that progress automatically leaves organized killing behind. After monuments, trials, memorials and declarations of “never again,” there is still murder. Technology changes. Administrative language changes. The body remains killable.
Within the album, “Still Murder” can be heard as the moment the promised progress reveals its destination. Pain progresses, death is certified, historical atrocity is invoked, and murder remains. The sequence does not advance toward resolution. It advances toward evidence that continuation itself may be the problem.
“Meat Processing” names the operation hidden within Cold Meat Industry. The label name is often remembered as an inspired piece of black humor, but this track exposes its literal structure. A living body becomes meat through death; meat becomes standardized material through processing; industry organizes the transformation at scale.
The phrase eliminates the individual before the process begins. It does not say whose meat, what body or what life preceded the material. Once something has entered processing, personal history becomes an obstruction. Weight, temperature, contamination and usable portions replace biography.
Industrial music performs a comparable operation upon sound. A recorded voice can be cut away from its speaker, repeated, filtered and inserted into a composition according to texture rather than original meaning. A scream becomes material. Speech becomes rhythm. Documentary evidence becomes atmosphere.
This does not make sound processing morally equivalent to bodily violence. The analogy reveals a shared structure of abstraction. To process something is to place distance between origin and use.
Karmanik’s label will repeatedly examine that distance. Bodies, religion, warfare, sexuality, murder and psychiatric disturbance enter packages whose formal control can appear beautiful. The aesthetic object processes distress into something collectible.
“Meat Processing” is therefore not only another morbid title. It is an early description of the enterprise being built around it. Cold Meat Industry will manufacture objects from the cultural remains of fear, flesh and death, then circulate them internationally through mail-order networks.
The cassette itself joins the processing line. Sound is recorded onto magnetic tape, duplicated across hundreds of shells, packaged and distributed. A private disturbance becomes standardized stock without becoming mass-market product. Industry has begun at miniature scale.
“Heart of Stone” closes by moving the album’s violence inward. Earth shatters, death receives certification, historical murder enters the sequence and bodies become meat. The final transformation is emotional mineralization. The heart survives by becoming something incapable of feeling.
A stone heart can signify cruelty, endurance or protection. To remain sensitive inside repeated exposure to violence may feel impossible. Hardening offers survival, but survival comes through the loss of responsiveness that might make survival meaningful.
The title also returns the album from meat to geology. “Shatterer of Earth” threatened the stone beneath the world. “Heart of Stone” places stone inside the body. The external landscape and internal organ exchange properties.
Discographic notes identify a sample from Pier Paolo Pasolini’s Salò, or the 120 Days of Sodom within this track. The film is itself an artwork about fascist power, commodified bodies and cruelty organized as ceremony. Removing dialogue from that cinematic structure and inserting it into an industrial cassette produces another layer of processing.
The sample carries emotional and historical authority because it arrives from a work already associated with extremity. Listeners who recognize the source bring the film’s images into the track. Those who do not recognize it may still hear vocal intensity detached from explanation.
This detachment can strengthen atmosphere while weakening critique. Pasolini places bodily degradation inside a political construction concerned with power, consumption and fascism. A sample may preserve the disgust while losing the argument. What remains is potent, but its potency no longer guarantees the same meaning.
Karmanik’s use of such material anticipates the difficult economy of later death industrial and power electronics. Cinema, documentary recordings and historical speech become resources from which intensity can be extracted. Recognition rewards the informed listener; anonymity permits the source to function as raw sound.
“Heart of Stone” ends the album without restoring the human voice to uncomplicated personhood. Speech has entered the machinery and been made to serve another object. The final heart may belong to the narrator, the listener, the artist or the system that can repeatedly process images of suffering without changing its operation.
The complete cassette forms a much tighter conceptual sequence than its primitive means might initially suggest. Earth, pain, official death, historical atrocity, continuing murder, processed flesh and petrified emotion are not random selections from a bag of shocking words. They describe successive reductions in the scale at which a person can remain human.
The world is broken. Pain becomes continuous. The institution recognizes death. History turns violence into a site and name. Murder persists. The body becomes meat. The heart becomes stone.
This movement is not a story with characters, but it has narrative pressure. Each title removes another layer of protection until nothing remains except inert material. The nursery has completed its terrible education.
The sound’s roughness keeps this conceptual structure from becoming too elegant. Pain in Progress is not a perfectly designed philosophical suite. It is agitated, repetitive and materially narrow. Its ideas often exceed the equipment available to contain them.
That imbalance creates much of its force. A sophisticated production might make these themes feel cinematic, giving atrocity and death a spectacular architecture. The cassette cannot sustain such grandeur. Its world remains cramped, closer to obsession than spectacle.
Karmanik’s punk inheritance is audible in this refusal to wait for better conditions. Punk offered more than speed or guitar style. It supplied permission to make an object before professional competence, public demand or institutional approval existed.
Crass and Throbbing Gristle provided complementary models. Crass demonstrated that record design, political confrontation, autonomous distribution and abrasive sound could form one total practice. Throbbing Gristle demonstrated that tape, imagery, performance and morally contaminated subject matter could be used to examine the machinery beneath respectable society.
Pain in Progress inherits both possibilities without duplicating either. Its politics remain far less explicit than Crass, and its conceptual framing less elaborate than Throbbing Gristle. What Karmanik receives is an attitude toward authorization. The object can exist because he decides to manufacture it.
The difference between this cassette and later Brighter Death Now is not simply that later work becomes harsher. The later project develops a more recognizable persona, vocal extremity and control over the relationship between repetition, distortion and subject matter. Pain in Progress remains closer to a laboratory where several identities are being tested.
Bomb the Daynursery contains traces of early electronic play, post-punk reduction, tape collage and the future death-industrial method. These tendencies have not yet been forced into one final character. The project can still mutate in several directions.
Brighter Death Now will narrow the field and intensify it. The name itself is a better public machine: three blunt words forming a slogan, promise and contradiction. Bomb the Daynursery is stranger, more juvenile and less stable. It sounds like a private joke whose humor may conceal genuine panic.
Later reissues placed the seven original pieces beneath the Brighter Death Now name, making practical sense once that identity became internationally recognized. The transfer also rewrites history subtly. The mature project adopts its precursor and makes the old recordings appear like an early chapter in one continuous career.
Your post’s original attribution preserves the break. This is Bomb the Daynursery, not yet Brighter Death Now, even though the same person and many of the same compulsions are present. Names matter because they reveal when an artist believed one identity had become insufficient.
The distinction resembles the difference between a person’s childhood name and adult public role. The later identity may explain what the earlier one became, but it cannot replace what the earlier one felt like before the destination was known.
Pain in Progress is valuable precisely because it does not know it will be absorbed into a celebrated death-industrial catalog. It does not know Brighter Death Now will continue for decades. It does not know CMI will expand from homemade cassettes into an internationally influential label with a visual and sonic language recognized almost instantly.
This uncertainty is embedded in every crude edge. The cassette does not behave like an origin myth because it has not yet learned that people will return to study its origin.
Placed after In the Shadow of Death, it also reveals something complicated about Karmanik’s role as curator. CMI-02 opened the label toward a community of other projects. CMI-03 immediately returns the first album-length release to Karmanik himself.
This can be read as self-prioritization, but it also exposes how inseparable the early label was from his own artistic development. Cold Meat Industry was not a neutral company discovering an existing scene from outside. Its identity grew through Karmanik’s attempts to find a form capable of containing his own work, then recognizing related necessities in others.
The label and artist raised one another. Releasing other projects enlarged the context in which his sounds could be understood. His own recordings established the emotional pressure through which the label selected other artists.
The nursery is therefore both private and collective. One person has placed the bomb, but a culture will grow around the crater.
The MP3 archive extends this process into a form the cassette’s maker could not have anticipated. A limited object whose circulation once depended upon copied lists, letters, money orders, envelopes and postal patience now arrives as a 50.7 MB folder. The magnetic tape’s vulnerability has been translated into endlessly duplicable data.
The transfer does not preserve everything. Cassette hiss may be captured, but the physical mechanism producing it is gone. The pause required to turn the tape disappears. The insert’s negative photograph becomes a small screen image, illuminated from behind rather than printed upon paper.
The MP3 also removes information through compression, but its cultural operation is expansive. Four hundred reported copies could reach only four hundred initial owners. The file can pass through thousands of hands without leaving its first holder.
Underground history often survives through this contradiction. Incomplete copies carry more context forward than perfect objects locked within private collections. Fidelity decreases while social reach increases.
The blog post restores part of what the folder alone cannot. The catalog number places the release back inside Cold Meat Industry’s early sequence. The cover restores a visual body. The year and artist name prevent the recordings from floating anonymously beneath the later Brighter Death Now identity.
Now the review adds another layer, but it cannot make the archive complete. No text can reproduce what it meant to receive CMI-03 through the mail when only two previous catalog numbers existed. That uncertainty belonged to its moment and cannot be reissued.
What can be recovered is the shape of the risk. Karmanik had ended one project, launched a label, gathered other artists and returned to an older name to make the label’s first album. Every element was unstable. The audience was small. The format was fragile. The aesthetic had no guarantee of becoming legible.
Pain in Progress turns that instability into its deepest subject. It is not a polished statement about suffering from someone standing safely beyond it. It is suffering entering manufacture before either the person or institution knows what the manufacture will do.
The title never promises that pain will end when its progress is complete. It may be progressing toward Brighter Death Now, Cold Meat Industry, another listener or another repetition. Progress simply means the machinery remains active.
CMI-01 was a death that produced life. CMI-02 was a shadow that gathered company. CMI-03 is the first sustained operation of the machine those objects accidentally assembled.
The tape turns. The body is processed. The heart hardens. The industry begins.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.