Alice In Wonderland No. 4 is where Randy Greif’s rabbit-hole machine begins to sound less like childhood disorientation and more like a deranged civic institution. The earlier discs trace Alice’s fall, bodily instability, social nonsense, kitchen violence, vanishing cats, and tea-table imprisonment. This fourth volume moves into a stranger emotional register: mock education, mock sorrow, mock song, and eventually mock law. Wonderland has always had rules, but here the rules begin wearing robes.
The track list makes the shift clear. The 1992 Staalplaat CD includes pieces such as “Sobs Choked His Voice,” “The Whiting,” “The Voice Of The Slugger,” “Beautiful Soup,” “Twelve Creatures,” “A Guilty Thing,” “The King And Queen Of Hearts,” “The Trial’s Beginning,” and “The Jury.” These titles place the disc around the Mock Turtle’s sentimental grotesquerie and the opening machinery of the trial. It is an important movement in Carroll’s story because nonsense begins to imitate institutions more directly: school, song, court, testimony, hierarchy, punishment.
That is why No. 4 feels heavier than its surface absurdity might suggest. The Mock Turtle is funny, but his sadness is theatrical and contagious. He sobs over a past that may not really exist, gives Alice a parody of education, and turns language into an inventory of puns, lessons, and self-pity. Greif is perfectly suited to this material because his Alice project already treats speech as unstable matter. Words do not simply carry meaning. They wobble, repeat, dissolve into phonemes, return as rhythm, and become strange little organisms with teeth.
The full Alice project has been described as a six-hour musical and textural setting of Carroll’s book, with spoken text often deconstructed into pure sound before returning to recognizable language. That method is especially powerful on this fourth volume because Carroll’s legal and educational language already feels corrupted from within. Greif does not need to make it absurd. He only has to amplify its absurdity until the listener hears how close official language can be to nonsense when authority protects it.
“Beautiful Soup” is a perfect example. In Carroll, it is a comic song, ridiculous and mournful, sung by a creature whose very identity is a joke about soup. But in Greif’s hands, such material can stop being merely funny and become uncanny. A little song becomes a ritual of appetite, species confusion, and sentimental performance. Who mourns whom? Who is food? Who is singing? Who is being consumed by the song? Wonderland keeps turning innocence into digestive metaphysics.
Then the trial material begins, and the emotional weather changes again. “A Guilty Thing,” “The King And Queen Of Hearts,” “The Trial’s Beginning,” “The Jury”: suddenly the nonsense world has a courtroom. This is one of Carroll’s sharpest moves. The book’s absurdity does not remain playful chaos. It organizes itself into law. That is more frightening. A mad tea party can be escaped. A mad court claims the right to judge you.
Greif’s sound-world makes that claim unstable. Voices become less trustworthy. Declarations feel like broken ceremony. The court does not sound like reason arriving to settle the dream. It sounds like the dream inventing bureaucracy. This is where fantasy and reality join with a nasty little click. Real institutions often work exactly this way when their language becomes self-protective: procedure continues even after meaning has fled the building.
The disc also demonstrates why Greif’s five-part structure matters. A shorter adaptation might treat these scenes as colorful episodes. Greif allows the listener to arrive worn down by Wonderland’s previous failures: failed identity, failed etiquette, failed time, failed conversation. By the time the trial begins, the listener understands that the court is not an interruption of madness. It is madness becoming official.
That makes No. 4 one of the most socially pointed volumes in the cycle. No. 1 asks what happens when the self changes shape. No. 2 asks what happens when society rewards nonsense. No. 3 asks what happens when bodies, animals, and signs detach from each other. No. 4 asks what happens when nonsense receives institutional authority. The answer is not comforting. It sings, sobs, teaches, accuses, and empanels a jury.
As a Private Release post, this disc belongs beautifully in the Greif sequence because it speaks to the archive’s interest in transmission and altered context. A familiar children’s text becomes a 1992 experimental CD. A courtroom parody becomes a sound-art study of authority. A song about soup becomes a little death ceremony. The archive does not merely preserve the object. It lets the object re-enter the present with new teeth.
Alice In Wonderland No. 4 is the point where Wonderland’s nonsense stops feeling like a private dream and starts behaving like public administration. The Mock Turtle sobs, the songs curdle, the King and Queen appear, the trial begins, and language puts on a wig. Greif hears the danger clearly: when absurdity gains authority, the joke no longer ends with laughter.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi.