The cover looks less like album artwork than a damaged memory somebody managed to rescue from a box. Two figures occupy an ordinary patch of grass near a hedge and a set of tall metal poles. One appears suspended in a rounded swing while the other stands farther back, but the photograph is too degraded to settle comfortably into description. Vertical scratches and seams divide the image into panels. Faces, gestures and distances have been partially swallowed by reproduction. It could be childhood documented from across a yard, a still from an abandoned home movie, or evidence from a day whose emotional importance was not understood until years later.
That uncertainty is an exact entrance into The Strange Girls. It’s OK To Be Happy gathers recordings made between 1999 and 2001 by Clayton Noone, Kaaterama “Motty” Morehu and Jon Arcus, three people in Dunedin making what Noone later called clean, chord-based country-rock songs. Clean is a wonderfully relative word here. The basic materials may be chord changes, guitars, drums and voices, but they reach us through muffled recording, tape damage, room sound and the unstable surfaces of New Zealand’s deep DIY underground. The songs are clean in intention, perhaps, while everything carrying them has acquired weather.
The first song, “Satan,” is also the first song from the first gig The Strange Girls ever played. That kind of beginning usually disappears. Bands rehearse, fail, reorganize themselves and later construct a cleaner origin story from whatever survives. Here the first public moment is placed at the entrance of an album assembled more than twenty years later. The recording does not arrive as an embarrassing preliminary sketch that must be excused before the mature work begins. It becomes the foundation stone.
Calling a first song “Satan” might suggest theatrical evil, metal spectacle or deliberate provocation, but The Strange Girls belonged to a musical culture where grand words could be placed inside deliberately reduced circumstances. Satan does not need thunder, fire or expensive production. The name can hang above a few people in a room, an unstable chord and a recording device struggling to contain what is happening. Cosmic conflict is brought down to household scale. The prince of darkness has arrived, but there may not be enough microphone cable.
That shrinking of mythology is part of the group’s beauty. Their songs carry titles such as “Control,” “Thug,” “In a Passionate Mood,” “Truly” and “Wasp,” words that appear direct enough to explain themselves until the music surrounds them with ambiguity. The Strange Girls do not build elaborate lyrical architecture around these terms. They let a small word sit inside damaged sound until it begins accumulating private associations. Control can mean discipline, emotional restraint, domination or the impossibility of holding a recording together. Truly can be an oath, a hesitation or the beginning of a sentence nobody manages to finish.
The group developed partly from the same Dunedin environment that allowed noise, folk, damaged pop and free playing to occupy the same social rooms. Noone’s earlier work in Armpit had embraced a more openly abrasive and collapsing form of rock. The Strange Girls did not abandon that freedom when they moved toward songs. They placed freedom inside the song form. Chords may be recognizable, but they are not required to behave professionally. Timing can sag, voices can sit behind the instruments, and distortion can obscure exactly the detail a commercial recording would have pulled forward.
This makes the album’s supposed country-rock identity especially interesting. Country music depends heavily upon direct emotional communication, familiar structures and the feeling that a song can be carried without elaborate equipment. The Strange Girls preserve those qualities while removing almost every guarantee normally attached to them. The listener receives the chord, ache and outline of the song, but the route has been damaged. It is country music transmitted through a wall, remembered after sleep or played from a cassette found beneath the seat of a car that no longer runs.
“Control” and “Girl by a Stream” establish the group’s ability to make repetition feel emotional rather than merely formal. Minor chords and persistent strumming do not necessarily lead toward a dramatic chorus or instrumental release. They create a place where feeling can remain without being resolved. “Girl by a Stream” is especially suggestive because the title offers an apparently peaceful image while the music belongs to a much more unstable emotional climate. A stream moves continuously, but the person beside it may be unable to move at all.
The Strange Girls’ lo-fi character is not only an aesthetic surface. It preserves the social conditions under which the music existed. These recordings were not waiting for a larger industry to notice and complete them. They circulated through tiny editions, lathe-cut records, cassettes and CD-Rs, formats that could be produced because someone cared enough to manufacture a small number without needing permission from a market. A song might reach twenty people, then disappear into cupboards, private collections and obsolete computer drives. Scarcity was not always manufactured exclusivity. Sometimes it was simply the natural size of the available machinery.
Root Don Lonie for Cash, the label Noone operated, belonged to that homemade ecology. Its name already rejects clean cultural presentation. It sounds like a mistranslated business instruction, a memorial to an unknown person, or a demand written on the back of a photograph. The label issued music because music had been made, not because every release could be translated into a stable product identity. Cassettes, tiny CD-Rs and lathe cuts became containers for whatever had happened recently enough to preserve.
The Strange Girls sound deeply connected to that attitude. They are not careless, but they do not equate care with correction. A recording can contain noise and still be treated as precious. A voice can be hard to hear and still carry the song. A photograph can be scratched almost beyond recognition and still deserve the front cover. Preservation does not always restore an object to imagined perfection. Sometimes it protects the damage because the damage is part of the object’s journey.
“Thug” and “Lyric” close the first side at opposite scales. “Thug” receives enough time to establish weight and atmosphere, while “Lyric” lasts less than two minutes, almost as though the title names a fragment rescued without the larger song that once surrounded it. Placing a piece called “Lyric” inside music whose words may be partially obscured is quietly funny. The lyric exists, but it refuses to behave like the sole delivery system for meaning. Guitar texture, tape grain and the distance of the voice communicate alongside language.
The second side opens with “In a Passionate Mood,” another title that sounds unusually formal for such weather-beaten music. Passion is not presented as operatic display. It is a condition the recording enters while remaining physically restrained. This may be one reason the album feels more emotionally convincing than records that announce feeling through technical emphasis. The Strange Girls do not increase fidelity, vocal volume or arrangement size to prove that passion has arrived. The mood exists within the same modest equipment and bodily limitations as everything else.
“OK” sits near the center of the album’s philosophy. Those two letters can mean genuine acceptance, reluctant agreement, emotional survival or the smallest answer a person can give when language is exhausted. It is not the same as excellent, healed, triumphant or complete. OK is sufficient. The title of the collection works similarly. It’s OK To Be Happy does not order anyone to become happy or claim that happiness erases sorrow. It grants permission.
That permission becomes more complicated because the collection appeared after Motty Morehu’s death in 2019. The title does not transform into grief merely because we know one of the central musicians had died, but knowledge changes the light around it. These recordings contain a living person singing and playing during years when nobody involved knew exactly how the material would later be assembled or heard. Happiness, preserved beside absence, does not betray the person who is gone. It becomes part of what their life continues giving.
This may be the most generous meaning available in the title. Grief can make happiness feel disloyal, as though continuing to experience pleasure reduces the seriousness of the loss. It’s OK To Be Happy rejects that hidden punishment. The life mattered enough to produce music, friendship, jokes, performances and memories. The loss remains enormous because those things existed. Happiness afterward does not cancel the price. It carries evidence of what made the price so high.
“Sleep” deepens that atmosphere through its very smallness. Sleep is restoration, disappearance, vulnerability and a rehearsal for absence, all contained in an ordinary nightly act. In lo-fi recording, sleep also describes the state of many sounds on the tape. Details seem buried but not dead. They can be awakened by attention. A voice that initially appears too distant begins to reveal shape after repeated listening. Noise once heard as interference becomes the room itself breathing around the performance.
“Truly” follows with a title that seeks certainty but cannot guarantee it. Truth in these recordings does not depend upon pristine documentation. The microphone may distort, the source may be many generations removed and the circumstances may be poorly remembered, yet the performance still tells the truth that it occurred. Three people occupied a room, listened to one another and produced something that could not be recreated after the fact.
“Wasp” closes the album with the smallest creature and the longest running time. A wasp can be nearly invisible until its sound enters the room, at which point attention becomes absolute. It is delicate, mechanical, social and dangerous. That makes it a useful final emblem for The Strange Girls. Their music is physically modest but difficult to ignore once heard properly. It carries a buzz inside the song form, an irritation or electric life that prevents the chords from becoming comfortable background.
The sequence is carefully shaped enough to feel like the band’s lost first album rather than a historical folder arranged by date. This is an important distinction. Chronology would tell us what happened in order; sequencing tells us what the surviving material can become now. The 2022 edition does not pretend the trio consciously recorded these ten songs as one LP. It asks whether an album was latent inside the scattered archive, waiting for somebody with enough distance to recognize its outline.
Fördämning Arkiv was especially suited to that work. The Swedish label emerged from a fascination with small-edition New Zealand releases, including lathe cuts whose obscurity was part of their actual manufacturing history rather than a later collector mythology. The geographical distance is beautiful: music made privately in Dunedin at the turn of the millennium is gathered two decades later by listeners in Gothenburg, pressed into five hundred LPs and sent outward again.
That route demonstrates how underground culture actually survives. It is rarely a straight ascent from obscurity to recognition. The music passes sideways through enthusiasts, trades, blogs, packages, old hard drives, record shops and people who remember names that search engines barely recognize. One person’s private enthusiasm becomes another person’s label project. A photograph is located. A musician writes notes. Someone masters the damaged recordings without bleaching away their age. The album that never existed begins occupying shelves.
The cover preserves that sideways movement. Its image does not promote the musicians or establish a fashionable visual identity. It withholds almost everything. We see distance, play equipment, vegetation and people whose identities have been softened by reproduction. The photograph’s damage resembles the music’s recording texture, but neither should be mistaken for emptiness. The missing information creates attention. We look harder because the image will not surrender itself immediately.
A swing is also an ideal object for music assembled from repetition. It travels forward and backward without progressing geographically, yet every return is altered by momentum, gravity and the body. Songs like these can circle a few chords for minutes without remaining still. Each repetition carries the memory of the previous one. The listener changes while the figure moves through the same arc.
The title therefore contains a larger philosophy of underground music. It is acceptable for art to be small, damaged, sincere, funny, emotionally excessive and technically incomplete. It is acceptable for a group to leave behind scattered objects rather than a career shaped for historical convenience. It is acceptable for happiness to appear inside downer rock, and for sadness to remain inside an album whose name offers permission to feel otherwise.
Motty’s death closed one version of The Strange Girls, but it did not erase the relationships preserved in these tapes. Jon Arcus’s departure after the early trio period did not make these years preliminary or lesser. Clayton Noone’s later work did not replace what happened here. Every phase remains complete in the particular connections it formed.
It’s OK To Be Happy is valuable because it does not clean those connections into a conventional origin story. It leaves the scratches on the photograph, the muffling around the voice and the uncertainty around the scene. We are allowed to receive the music without owning every fact that produced it. Somewhere inside the grain, three people are still playing the first song at their first gig, before any of them knows how far the sound will travel.