The title sounds permissive: let the musicians play what they want. It could suggest looseness, indulgence or a recording session with nobody willing to say no. Instead, the album reveals that freedom inside an ensemble requires intense listening. Playing what you want cannot mean ignoring everybody else. It means finding out whether your desire can enter the larger construction without flattening the desires already moving through it.
Man Forever is led by drummer and composer John Colpitts, also known as Kid Millions, but it does not operate like the usual solo project with supporting musicians arranged behind one personality. Colpitts creates rhythmic systems and invites other players inside them. The drums may determine gravity, but the music develops through cooperation, collision and the willingness of strong individual voices to become part of something they cannot completely control.
That principle is audible immediately on “You Were Never Here.” Percussion begins tapping out a peculiar entrance before upright bass, piano, harps and the voices of Yo La Tengo widen the field. Georgia Hubley, Ira Kaplan and James McNew do not arrive as celebrity decorations placed on top of the composition. Their voices behave like another instrumental family, softening certain edges while making the surrounding rhythms feel even stranger.
The piece keeps refusing the shape it appears ready to take. It suggests jazz, then choral music, then a form of minimalism driven by repeating figures. Mary Lattimore and Brandee Younger add harp without turning the track into something angelic or ornamental. The instrument flickers through the arrangement, sometimes offering light and sometimes making the music feel more unstable, as though the strings belong to a machine whose purpose has not yet been explained.
The title “You Were Never Here” suits the constantly changing structure. Each section seems capable of becoming the track’s permanent location, but the composition keeps moving before anyone can settle. A melodic idea arrives, leaves evidence, and disappears into another combination of players. By the end, the listener may remember several rooms without being certain how they were connected.
Rhythm remains the thread through these changes. Colpitts has spent much of Man Forever’s history exploring what happens when percussion is treated not as accompaniment but as sustained physical material. Earlier versions of the project could reduce the idea almost to ritual: multiple drummers generating overtones, or two people facing one drum and striking it until repetition altered the surrounding air. Here that discipline has not vanished. It has become hospitable.
The presence of TIGUE Percussion is essential to that expansion. Their playing makes complicated meter feel bodily rather than academic. Patterns interlock, separate and shift their emphasis, but the music never sounds like an examination designed to test whether the listener can count correctly. The pleasure comes from surrendering to a pulse whose internal machinery remains slightly beyond immediate comprehension.
“Ten Thousand Things” brings this quality forward. The percussion stomps and clangs while the voices of Colpitts and Nick Hallett add a ceremonial quality that sits somewhere between song, chant and invented folklore. Mary Lattimore’s harp moves through the compound rhythms with a different sense of time, allowing resonant strings to hang in the air while the drums continue measuring forward motion underneath them.
The title has an ancient breadth, suggesting the countless forms and objects that make up existence. The track responds by assembling a small universe from contrasting materials. Metal, skin, breath, voice and strings retain their individual textures while participating in one repeating organism. It is crowded without becoming cluttered.
That distinction may be the album’s central achievement. Many musicians are present, and their backgrounds cross experimental rock, contemporary composition, improvisation, jazz, vocal music and electronics. Yet the record rarely feels like a guest list being read aloud. The collaborators are recognizable through what they contribute, but the music does not pause to display them individually beneath a spotlight.
“Debt and Greed” is the most concise and immediately songlike piece, though it remains an odd little machine. Colpitts establishes a lean, circular groove while Phil Manley’s guitar sends bright, processed lines across the rhythm. Ben Lanz adds horns, and the layered singing carries a surprising trace of soft-rock harmony. The arrangement sounds almost cheerful until the words reveal a world reduced to anger, economic pressure and willful neglect.
The contrast is effective because the music does not illustrate greed with obvious ugliness. It gives the subject an attractive surface, closer to the way destructive systems often present themselves in ordinary life. The trains continue moving. The harmonies rise. The machinery works beautifully while the people inside it discover that beauty and justice are separate questions.
Colpitts’ drumming here demonstrates how much force can be produced without constant eruption. He repeats the groove with the concentration of someone testing a structure for hidden weaknesses. Small accents become important because the basic motion is so disciplined. The drums do not merely keep the track together; they make the lyrics’ social machinery physically audible.
The first side therefore moves from an almost nine-minute collaborative landscape to a compact pop construction without making either form seem more legitimate than the other. Length is treated as a compositional requirement rather than a measure of seriousness. Some ideas need room to mutate. Others become stronger by arriving, making their cut and leaving.
“Twin Torches” opens the second half with Laurie Anderson, whose voice immediately changes the listener’s relationship to language. She has a rare ability to speak plainly while making the sentence sound as though it has arrived from a dream, a scientific report and an old myth simultaneously. Her violin and voice appear among hovering vocal textures before the percussion enters with tremendous force.
This is the point where the drummer at the center of the project becomes impossible to overlook. The earlier pieces often conceal their difficulty inside arrangement and atmosphere. “Twin Torches” allows the physical labor to come forward. Colpitts’ playing becomes thunderous, but the detail remains intact. Rolls, strikes and shifting patterns do not create a shapeless explosion. They feel directed, almost architectural, as though each burst is extending or supporting the strange structure Anderson is describing.
The Quince vocal ensemble adds another layer of human sound that does not function like a conventional chorus. Their voices hover, gather and change the scale of the piece. At moments they resemble light entering through high windows; elsewhere they feel like the building itself beginning to sing.
Anderson’s presence could easily dominate a lesser composition because her voice carries so much accumulated character. Man Forever gives her a role large enough to matter but refuses to become merely a Laurie Anderson backing track. The percussion answers her, surrounds her and occasionally seems ready to swallow the narration before withdrawing just enough to preserve the relationship.
That balance illustrates what “play what they want” actually demands. Laurie Anderson must remain unmistakably Laurie Anderson. Colpitts must drum with the intensity central to his work. The vocal ensemble, percussionists and other players must also retain their own languages. The piece succeeds not by sanding those identities into neutrality but by finding a construction strong enough to hold them all.
The closing “Catenary Smile” is named after the curve made by a hanging chain or cable suspended from two points. That image offers a useful way to hear the whole record. The music is held between different musical forces, and its shape is produced by the tension among them. Remove the weight, gravity or opposing supports and the curve disappears.
The track begins with anxious rhythmic movement and voices that seem both devotional and unsettled. Nick Hallett’s layered vocals create height above the drums, while fragments of melody drift through the increasingly complex arrangement. Like the opener, it continually hints that a stable song is about to emerge, then allows the rhythm to pull everything into another configuration.
Its subject, humanity’s habit of assigning human intention to objects and systems, is appropriate for a percussion album. Drums are especially vulnerable to being described as though they possess desires: they chase, argue, march, threaten or breathe. Of course the instruments do none of those things alone. A person strikes them, another person hears the pattern, and between action and perception the object acquires a temporary personality.
Man Forever plays inside that transformation. The instruments are physical things with material limits, but collective attention makes them appear conscious. Harps shimmer, drums insist, horns warn, and voices seem to emerge from the building rather than the mouths that produced them. The album does not ask us to stop imagining life inside sound. It asks us to notice how eagerly the mind creates it.
The cover contributes a little comedy to this seriousness. Colpitts appears in a suit, tie and sunglasses, holding a percussion mallet while standing near a “No Entry” sign. He resembles a businessman who has taken a wrong turn into a damaged office and decided to conduct the ruins. The words of the title have been broken across the image so that MAN FOREVER and PLAY WHAT THEY WANT overlap, almost turning the project’s name into an instruction.
That instruction is not complete anarchy. The record contains too much precision for that. It is closer to organized permission. Each musician is allowed to bring a full musical identity, but everyone must listen closely enough to discover where that identity can live among the others.
This is why the album feels joyful even when individual passages become tense or severe. The joy comes from capability meeting trust. Colpitts has gathered musicians who could each command an entire recording, then created situations where authority circulates instead of remaining fixed.
A drummer leads by making room.
A guest contributes by entering the structure rather than standing above it.
A complex rhythm becomes inviting because the body can feel what the mind has not yet counted.
The result is not jazz, rock, minimalism, contemporary classical music or experimental pop, though each description catches part of it. The record is more accurately understood as a meeting whose participants have agreed that the meeting itself should produce something none of them could have brought in alone.
They play what they want.
What they want changes when they hear one another.